Wednesday, November 7, 2007

Aaron post 10

Aaron Childree

When the Supreme Court case Roe v. Wade finally came to a close on January 22, 1973, a huge change had been made to the laws of the United States. Anti-abortion laws were declared unconstitutional and were said to violate the privacy of the women wanting an abortion. The court decided that during the first trimester there could be no restrictions on abortion and after that the state could intervene in some form (information on Roe v. Wade is from tourolaw.edu). This case caused a huge controversy and split the nation into those for abortion (pro-choice) and those against it (pro-life). This controversy slowly escalated over time until suddenly people were being killed over the issue. The controversy continues to this day and abortion is still an important political and legal issue.

Part 1

The anti-abortion movement had small and peaceful beginnings. John O’Keefe, known as the “father of rescue” (Wrath of Angels, p.78) was one of the first anti-abortionists to begin to organize peaceful sit-ins at abortion clinics. O’Keefe was a firm believer in “the power of nonviolence” (Wrath of Angels, p.79). He created an organization called the “Pro-Life Non-Violent Action Project” (Wrath of Angels, p.89) in which he would gather relatively small groups of protesters to gather around abortion clinics to hopefully interfere enough to close down the clinic for the day in order to send a message. Some of the clinics would decide to close down before the protesters even arrived and there were usually no arrests made. The idea was to get the point that abortion is murder across in a nonviolent way. O’Keefe realized that you can not fight against violence by being violent (similar to the beliefs of Mahatma Gandhi and Martin Luther King).

Next came Michael Bray, the anti-abortion movement’s “father of violence” (Wrath of Angels, p.78). Bray started as a participant in some of O’Keefe’s sit-ins but began to turn towards more militant ideas. He and his friend Thomas Spinks began to make plans to bomb abortion clinics. “Their first target was the Reproductive Care Center, a clinic in Dover Delaware, which Bray had scouted out while visiting nearby relatives” (Wrath of Angels p. 86). They bombed the clinic in January of 1984. Spinks described the experience: “So Mike opened the hatchback, and I grabbed a log and threw it through the door. Mike was to the right of me, and he threw a cinder block through the window, the big plate of glass. We began to throw the cans and things of gas inside” (Wrath of Angels, p.87). Bray and Spinks did not think that what they were doing was wrong; they thought it was for the good of society. Spinks later said, “it would be okay to destroy buildings. We saw them as death camps. So we came to the agreement that it was okay to destroy these places as long as it was carefully carried out so that no human life would be hurt in the process” (Wrath of Angels, p.86) This marked the beginning of the more militant and destructive side of the anti-abortion movement. There was still no talk of harming other human lives, but the ideas of nonviolence were slowly being pushed away and labeled ineffective.

Another anti-abortion activist that attempted to get her point across in destructive and rebellious ways was Joan Andrews. Like most activists, Andrews began by participating in peaceful sit-ins but soon became frustrated and began to turn to violence and destruction. Andrews started driving by “St. Louis-area clinics late at night to inject superglue, a remarkably tough adhesive, into door locks to seal them shut” (Wrath of Angels, p.193). Soon Andrews was “getting arrested throughout Pennsylvania” (Wrath of Angels, p.193). Joan Andrews finally got her “big break” in Pensacola. On March 26, 1988, became frustrated during a sit-in she was participating in. She entered The Ladies Center clinic and began tearing apart the equipment. “While Andrews was yanking on the wires, two police officers arrived and grabbed her” (Wrath of Angels, p. 201). Andrews was then taken to jail and given an offer of probation which she quickly refused. “Joan Andrews didn’t want a deal; she saw an opportunity in Pensacola to challenge the system” (Wrath of Angels, p.203). Andrews was sentenced to 5 years in prison and decided to use her time behind bars to make a statement with total noncooperation. She expressed some of her ideas in a speech before she went to jail: “I do recommend fasting two or three times a week in jail and praying constantly- but total noncooperation. Going limp where you have to be carried to your cell- total disobedience. Now let me ask you, what jail would want you? You will create such a disturbance in the minds and hearts of all the people you come in contact with that they are going to say, wow, they really mean it” (Wrath of Angels, p.204). Joan Andrews’s noncooperative show in prison received lots of attention and caused large problems for the justice system until she was finally released.

Soon after, the anti-abortion movement took a turn for the worst. Activists started using Genesis 9:6 to establish the morality of “justifiable homicide”. The verse reads: “Whoever sheds the blood of man, by man shall his blood be shed; for in the image of God has God made man” (Genesis 9:6, NIV). This verse is often seen as advocating the use of the death penalty in legal systems are more loosely as a “what goes around comes around” type of thing, but some activists saw it as a call to carry out God’s justice themselves by killing abortion doctors. Two such activists were Shelley Shannon and Paul Hill. Shannon shot George Tiller in August of 1993 and Hill shot and killed John Britton in July of 1994. These killings gave an understandably bad reputation to the anti-abortion movement and crippled its progress.

So why did everything turn sour so fast? The answer is frustration. Anti-abortion activists were looking for change, and no matter how hard they tried, they didn’t see it. They could shut down a clinic for a day, but it would open the next day and be back to business as usual. So the activists began to attempt to destroy the clinics. Abortions would then be stalled for a short period of time, but the clinics would find ways to provide abortions anyways. It just didn’t seem like any progress was being made. The final act of frustration, the killing of abortion doctors, was certainly a drastic step. But instead of making progress, it set the whole movement back to square one. How could people take pro-life advocates seriously if they are taking life away? They were now just a bunch of insane, murderous hypocrites. Changing the legal system takes lifetimes of slow and patient work, and the anti-abortion activists weren’t willing to be that patient.

Part 2

Randall Terry was a very important figure in the anti-abortion movement. “He had a gift, a relentlessness, that made it possible for him to talk to perfect strangers” (Wrath of Angels, p.241). He was one of the first people to take the anti-abortion movement to a national level. The fact that Terry was a Protestant Christian has a lot to do with why he decided to get involved with protests and “contentious actions”. First of all, because Terry wasn’t Catholic, he didn’t have to answer to the higher officials of the Catholic Church. Protestantism is less unified and structured and allows people to read the Bible and come to their own conclusions. Naturally, this leads to more freedom to carry out your believes without interference from the church. Another factor is that Christians believe in what McVeigh and Sikkink refer to as “moral absolutism” (God, Politics, and Protest, p.1432) Christians believe that anyone who doesn’t believe in Christianity will go to hell and that is why they believe they are doing the right thing by attempting to impose their beliefs on others. Yet another reason why Terry felt so compelled to protest abortion was because, like all Christians, he believed that all humans are sinful. Because of this he saw that people weren’t going to stray from their immoral ways on their own and took it upon himself to help push them to change.

Part 3

Article 1

KILL FOR LIFE?

[By Lisa Belkin]

New York Times; Oct 30, 1994; ProQuest Historical Newspapers The New York Times (1851 - 2004)

pg. SM47

Article 2

Is Abortion Violence a Plot? Conspiracy Is Not Confirmed

By TIMOTHY EGAN

New York Times (1857-Current file); Jun 18, 1995; ProQuest Historical Newspapers The New York Times (1851 - 2004)
pg. 1


The first article talks about the rapid evolution of the anti-abortion movement from peaceful sit-ins to ruthless murder. It mentions how ridiculous it is that pro-life advocates think that the best way to get their point across is to kill. They say that they are trying to save lives but now they are taking it away. The article talks a lot about Roy McMillan, an anti-abortionist who advocates “justifiable homicide” but says that he has no plans to kill anyone. The article also mentions Paul Hill and his murder of abortion doctor John Britton. Hill was close friends with McMillan and they shared a lot of the same ideas. The article says that government officials were trying to tie many of these political extremists together in order to uncover any conspiracies that might be going on.

The second article talks about how the government was trying to get information from Shelley Shannon on other anti-abortion extremists in order to establish whether or not there is a large conspiracy going on between anti-abortion activists who are willing to kill to get their point across. Shannon was unwilling to give any names even though she was already serving a ten-year sentence for the attempted murder of George Tiller, an abortion doctor.

Both articles mention that the federal government was investigating these murder cases closely and looking for any hints to a possible conspiracy. It seems that it was very widely believed that these murders were connected and that an “anti-abortion crime circle” was under operation. These articles also seem fairly intent on pointing out that they think the ideas of these murderers are crazy and ridiculous. This is probably because these extreme views are harmful to both sides of the debate. It harms the reputation of anti-abortionists by giving people reason to believe that they are just a bunch of lunatics, and it doesn’t help those for abortion because their doctors are being killed. Both sides wanted to stay away from supporting these views and the articles that were written at the time reflect that mentality.










1st image is from www.fadp.org

2nd image is from www.childrenneedheroes.com

The first image is a picture of Paul Hill the day before he is to be executed for murdering an abortion doctor. He seems to be shown smiling in order to show just how crazy he really is. He still believes that what he did was right and thinks that he will be rewarded by God in heaven for carrying out His work on earth. The second image is of Shelley Shannon, another person who shot an abortion doctor. This image also shows her smiling, but for a completely different reason. The site that this photo comes from (childrenneedheroes.com) is trying to say that Shannon should be seen as a hero and that she is smiling because she knows she has done the right thing. This site is trying to tell young children that they should be more like Shelley Shannon. The Children Need Heroes newsletter claims to be “Honoring the brave men and women who, at great personal cost, used force to defend preborn children from unjust violence” (childreneedheroes.com). Whereas the New York Times articles gave a more neutral and factual account of the happenings, it seems that these images are being used to aggressively promote one view on the issue.

The fight over the legality of abortion turned into a huge debate that included religious, political, and moral issues. It really is sad that some people can say they are “pro-life” and then turn into murderers. While the abortion issue continues to be a very difficult problem to solve, I think most people can now agree that violence will not help either side. This issue will not be resolved by destroying abortion clinics or even by killing doctors. If people want something to be changed they need to understand that it takes a lot of time and patience.

Kim post 10


Kim Hambright

Images and text alike are meant to impact their viewer. Whether in a positive or negative way, in support of a cause, or in opposition to a cause, both images and rhetoric speak to the viewer on a personal level. An image, by definition, is visual, and therefore makes an instantaneous impact on the viewer. While there may be subtext to the image, as well as underlying meanings that require more time and extensive visual analysis, a viewer is generally able to generate an opinion or understanding of an image in a very short period of time. Text however, requires more attention; this includes the obvious, reading, but also analysis. It is pertinent for a reader to fully comprehend and understand the words on the page for one to reach an understanding of the meaning of a written work. Just as people are different, so are the ways in which they understand images and textual pieces. The genre with the most lasting influence therefore, is indeterminable. For some, a visual image of an aborted fetus may burn into their mind for years; while for others, a Biblical passage about life may have a greater impact. Neither rhetoric nor images can be said to have the longest lasting influence on people, because influence is personal and unique to every individual.

After the trial of Roe vs. Wade, anti-abortion activists began taking a violent approach to protesting. Beginning with Bray and Sprinks in the early 1980’s setting off homemade car bombs, the often evangelical Christians took matters into their own hands. Activists moved from relatively small homemade explosive devices to larger explosive devices, and from attacking individuals to attacking buildings and clinics. Anti-abortionists vandalized abortion clinics, damaging equipment and personal property, and held prayer sessions outside of clinics all while claiming to be fighting for the “Army of God.” As time went on protestors became even more violent, committing such crimes as arson, assault, and even murder. Two radical supporters of the anti-abortion movement should be noted: Joan Andrews and Michael Griffin. In March of 1986, Joan Andrews, nicknamed “Saint Joan,” set fire to The Ladies Center, an abortion clinic in Pensacola, Florida. She received a sentence of five years in prison for the damages she caused, and instead of turning their backs, the anti-abortion community supported her. She was considered the first martyr of the movement, and other protestors looked to her as an iconic figure. Similarly Michael Griffin was sentenced due to actions prompted by his involvement with the anti-abortion movement. In March of 1993, Griffin shot abortion doctor David Gunn in a parking lot. The only explanation he gave was a statement that he felt God wanted him to. He felt that it was his personal duty to take the life of a man whom he felt had taken the lives of so many innocent unborn children.

The gradual increase in violence associated with the anti-abortion movement can be explained in several different ways. First off, they were not being heard. Protestors had been rioting and picketing, speaking out and fighting for years and nothing had been done to illegalize abortions. Understandably, the people associated with the movement became frustrated: they wanted to get their point across, they wanted to change the laws, and nothing had happened. Their increase in violence can be seen as a stronger attempt to be heard. With homemade explosives, firearms and lighters, the activists felt they would be able to make more of an impact. In another direction, the increase in violent protests could be seen as a result of improvements in technology, and one’s increased ability to possess more dangerous weapons. Since the technology was more readily available to them, protestors became involved in crimes of opportunity. For example, Shelley found the directions for making a pipe bomb on the internet and was able to buy all of the materials she needed at her local hardware store, so what is keeping her from bombing a place she deems evil? While the reasons for the violent uprisings may be debatable, the actual events are written in the history books. After the moral and political awakening that was the Roe vs. Wade case, anti-abortionists became vocal, and eventually violent. Their malicious and sometimes homicidal actions brought their stories to newspapers all over, and gave their stories and opinions exactly the kind of publicity that they had been aiming for.



A group of extremist protesters at an anti-abortion rally.
http://msnbcmedia2.msn.com/j/msnbc/Components/Photos/070424/070424_abortion_hmed_4p.hmedium.jpg

Paul Hill, Father Trosch, and Andrew Cabot at the trial of Michael Griffin.-

http://images.google.com/imgres?imgurl=http://www.christiangallery.com/Hill.jpg&imgrefurl=http://www.christiangallery.com/spr95new.html&h=336&w=484&sz=22&hl=en&start=2&um=1&tbnid=8Us6sL7OXscq8M:&tbnh=90&tbnw=129&prev=/images%3Fq%3DMichael%2BGriffin%2BDavid%2BGunn%26svnum%3D10%26um%3D1%26hl%3Den%26sa%3DG


Michael Griffin reportedly told authorities that he shot David Dunn because God had asked him to. Strangely enough, according to McVeigh and Sikkink, and Protestant approval, Griffin’s actions would be justified. As mentioned in the article, religion, though not the only factor influencing anti-abortionists’ behavior, was certainly a part of the reason many anti-abortionists “acted out.” The strong faith of the people, specifically Christianity, validated their actions, whether legal or illegal. It was Michael Griffin’s claim that upon seeing David Gunn in the gas station that fateful day, God asked him to warn the doctor of his wrong-doings. Griffin was apparently also told by God that Dunn’s punishment for taking so many lives, was to have his own life taken. Michael Griffin was just the man to do it. Strong in his faith, and even stronger in his beliefs, Griffin felt that his actions were justified to the Lord, and that no matter what happened to him on earth, he would have a place in Heaven. Unafraid of the consequences, Griffin even reported to the authorities not long after the murder, claiming that he had taken the doctor’s life.

Some Protestants, though not all, would agree with the actions of Michael Griffin. As the cartoon satirizes, people strong in their faith and moral codes even testified in favor of him at his trial. For those who believe in Divine Intervention, and those who believe in God’s prescence in everyday life, believing Griffin’s assertion that God had wanted him to shoot Gunn would not be difficult. It is for the reason of religion alone that Protestants may have agreed with the actions of David Griffin, actions that would usually have been defined as “heinous” and “evil.”

Anthony Lewis’ article, “Right to Life,” from the New York Times, reads very similarly to Risen and Thomas’ book, Wrath of Angels. Like the book, the article takes an obvious liberal standpoint, not only taking on the position that murder is wrong, but also that anti-abortion protests are wrong. A specific excerpt from the passage reads, “It is time to be serious about the menace of anti-abortion violence.” While the article mainly focuses around the death of abortion doctor David Gunn, it also Lewis criticizes actions of Michael Griffin, the man accused of murdering the doctor, along with the anti-abortion movement in general. In his opinion, the protesters “are religious fanatics that want to impose their version of God’s word on the rest of us.” He denounced their use of Biblical reasoning to make their point, and reported their unification of Church and State as unconstitutional. Clearly compatible with the book, both works would agree with the statement that violent anti-abortionists have gone too far. As Lewis claims in the article, they need to be stopped.

An article printed on May 10, 1990, also by the New York Times, entitled “95 Abortion Protesters are Freed,” discusses anti-abortionist actions in a much more objectified manner. The article consists mainly of stated facts about the arrest, trial, sentencing and release of anti-abortionists associated with the raid of an abortion clinic, led by Joan Andrews. Little bias is detectable, especially considering the inclusion of personal statements from Joan Andrews and her lawyer. Unlike Risen and Thomas’ book, the material in the article is presented in a way that allows the reader to make up their own minds about the actions of the anti-abortionists. The closing statement, “One leader of the protesters said a prayer vigil was scheduled at an abortion clinic in Burlington on Thursday morning,” even offers a way for the readers to express their agreement with and sympathy for the convicted protesters.

When searching for images on the anti-abortion movement, I discovered something: they aren’t easy to find. When I was searching the New York Times for articles however, my search was very bountiful. Though I’m not entirely sure as to the reason of this, I can attribute it to the ease of textual production. To write an article about an event, one must not necessarily attend the event, while it would be impossible to photograph an event without actually being there. Though the riots and protests were a big deal at the time, the number of people present at such events nowhere compared to the number of people all across America and beyond that heard about them. Text is also much easier to manipulate. Especially at the time, it was difficult to capture images of anti-abortionist activity in a way that would lead the viewer to only one conclusion. Images were open to interpretation by the viewer, and he or she could use his or her own personal beliefs to evaluate a photograph and form an opinion. Working with text however, allowed a writer to lead the readers in any way they wanted to. Overall, the text I found was much more diverse in opinion compared to the images. Though I realize my own personal beliefs influence my opinion, I felt that it was difficult to find photographs or images in support of the anti-abortion movement. I also found it interesting that everywhere I looked I saw the words “anti-abortion.” Though that may be the term deemed appropriate for such extremists, I had always known those against abortion to be called “pro-life.” In a way, I feel this use of language almost automatically denounces the actions of those against abortion. Instinctively one hears “anti” and a negative connotation is given, whereas if they had been called “pro-life,” a more positive connotation would have been given to them. Additionally, I’m curious to know how the protesters identify themselves, as “pro-life” or as “anti-abortionists,” and even if it matters at all. To me, the simple choice of words adds a great deal of disapproval to the actions described. Justified or unjustified, “anti-abortionist riots” sounds exceedingly more dangerous than “pro-life riots.” Ultimately, propaganda through rhetoric was (and is) extremely prominent, and it is understandable that it is still easier to find than images to this day.

Tawny N post 10

Tawny Najjar

“Religion provides life, the world, and history with meaning, through a sacred reality which transcends those mundane realities. But in doing so, religion establishes a perceived objective reality above and beyond temporal life, the world, and history, that then occupies ad independent and privileged position to act – through those who believe in the religion – back upon the mundane world. That which is sacred and transcends temporal, earthly reality also stands in the position to question, judge, and condemn temporal earthly reality. In this way, the ultimate legitimator of the status quo can easily become its ultimate judge.” – Smith (McVeigh 1430)

Abortion has long been an extremely controversial topic among Americans. One reason for this conflict is that this issue directly relates to many American women, and challenges moral beliefs and ideas. Opposition to ideas that are considered by some to be “amoral” is inevitable, but a question that arises from this opposition is: How far is too far? Are there valid reasons for protestors to resort to violence? Many protestors that represented various religious groups believed that they had a “God-given” right to fight for what they believed to be moral. Actions speak louder than words, and this idea was clearly shown during the anti-abortionist movement.

The Roe versus Wade decision launched what came to be known as the anti-abortionist movement. In this decision, the court abolished all laws prohibiting abortion. They declared that abortion was permissible for all reasons up until the fetus reaches a point in which it is “viable,” which is when it has the potential to live outside of its mother’s uterus. This period of “viability” began during the second trimester of pregnancy. This decision triggered many debates about under what circumstances abortion is permissible and acceptable.

The beginning of the anti-abortionist movement was characterized by political involvement. Rallies were organized to recruit other to join the cause. In 1981, Michael Bray attended a rally in Bowie in support of the county executive, who had proposed a ban on abortion (Risen 83). Group involvement was mostly seen in churches. The Assemblies of God, for example, formed the backbone of the protests in Pensacola, protesting every Saturday morning. This became the first large-scale anti-abortionist protest campaign in the South, as well as the first in the nation to be dominated and organized by Fundamentalist Protestants, rather than Catholics (Risen 197). Projects were developed, such as the Pro-Life Non-Violent Action Project, started by Bray and O’Keefe in Gaithersburg, Maryland. This protest project occurred on November 17, in which forty-seven people, including seventeen Protestant and Catholic members were arrested. Over one hundred protestors blocked the doors of the clinic. This was the first publicized protest, gaining media recognition from the Washington Post. Anti-abortionists used propaganda as well, creating a documentary called The Silent Scream. This documentary was produced by a former abortion doctor who turned anti-abortionist. It contained traumatic footage of an ultrasound examination conducted during an abortion. This was the most successful piece of propaganda and one of the most effective recruiting tools (Risen 198).

However, protests, posters, and letters did not inflict the change that anti-abortionists were demanding. In an effort to make their point more noticeable, protestors started to resort to violence, starting with vandalism, and ending with total destruction of buildings. Joan Andrews, a Pro-Life advocate, spray-painted anti-abortion graffiti in clinic walls, superglued the door locks, and spread noxious liquids throughout clinics in St. Louis, which forced a temporary closure. Another advocate, Michael McMonagle, staged sit-ins, and invaded clinics and damaged equipment whenever possible. Besides picketing and inflicting damage on clinics, protestors started to make more personal attacks against clinic employees. McMonagle picketed the homes of abortion doctors, clinic owners, and clinic staffers (Risen 193). John Burt, another protestor, also personalized his protests against doctors and clinic staffers.

The final stage of the protest movement was obvious violence. Some protestors felt that this method would be the most effective way to get through to people and stop abortion. As John Burt stated, “When the history of this period is written, it won’t be the pickets or the letter-writers who will be the heroes. It’s going to be the bombers” (NY Times, Jan 18 1985). Clinic bombing began in 1984, started by Bray and Spinks. The Wheaton blast, occurring on November 19, 1984, was the first clinic bombing to make national news. One protestor gave the statement, “Yes, it is just…Is it prudent? No. But it is just to respond to violence against people by destroying property. Human life is far more valuable than property. Pro-lifers are going to act…The question is what shape that action will take” – O’Keefe (Risen 94). Protestors created the group, The Defenders of the Defenders of Life, which was a support group for clinic bombers and their families. Clinic bombing reached a high in 1984. Those activists who did not want to resort to this level of violence instead turned to civil disobedience. Half of the abortion providers claimed that they had become the “targets of anti-abortion ‘harassment,’” a politically loaded term that clinic personnel and abortion-right advocates used to describe civil disobedience and even legal protest activity, such as picketing (Risen 241).

The bombing in Pensacola was the final straw for the government. On Christmas of 1984, three bombs destroyed twp clinics and a doctor’s office. Matthew Goldsby was arrested for the bombings. This event gave people the impression that the anti-abortion movement was taking a turn to extremism. As Risen stated in the reading, “The Pensacola bombers were not active members of the anti-abortion movement and in fact had no ties to any of the Pensacola activist leaders. What they shared with the more visible activists was religious fundamentalism and a belief in the literal power of the Scriptures to tell them that abortion was an unholy stain on America” (Risen 198). Although the bombing in Pensacola marked the extremism that the anti-abortion movement was starting to appeal to, the protests did not stop there. In 1986, Joan Andrews was convicted of a third-degree burglary for entering The Ladies Center clinic in Pensacola and damaging equipment there. The anti-abortion movement unified behind a “free Joan Andrews” campaign, which gave the movement a second wind (Risen 187). This campaign gained a lot of media coverage. “It was one of the great ironies of the anti-abortion cause that fundamentalist Protestants, who had until them steered clear of anti-abortion activism in part because of their antipathy toward all thing Catholic, were finally mobilized by the plight of a woman who was feverishly Catholic” (Risen 188).

Religious protestors felt that they were morally obligated to fight for their ethical beliefs. As Appleby said, “There is a crime going on, the murder of babies…This is a war. We’re at a battlefield. We’re soldiers for Christ” (Risen 202). In their study, McVeigh and Sikkink came up with proven reasons for why these people accept contentious tactics as a means of protest. These reasons were a belief in coercive moralism, a belief that all humans are sinful, and a belief that one’s moral standards are being threatened. Religious groups may feel that their moral standards are being threatened, and so may be “acting defensively” to preserve moral order. When they feel threatened, groups may be more likely to resort to contentious tactics. Volunteering for religious organizations may also implicate that one may be accepting of contentious tactics. Joining an organization requires that one believes in what that organization believes. There is a unity among those people, an understanding. These anti-abortionists believe that they were in a struggle of “good versus evil,” “God versus the world.” As McVeigh stated, “If human history is about God struggling with Satan, about right struggling against an indifference to what is right, about a religious community embattled by external forces, it only makes sense that contentious tactics will, by analogy, be required for social change” (McVeigh 1450).

One example of a Protestant man who believed in the use of contentious tactics was Michael Bray, the man who started clinic bombing. He was convinced to “fight with everything at [his] disposal – tools of politics as well as weapons of war – and that it was appropriate for the godly man to take the law into his own hands, because his hands were the tools of the Lord” (Risen 82). Bray believed that “any members of the ‘elect’ – anyone saved by God through faith – had the right to ‘rebellion against idolatrous and tyrannical sovereigns’…it was his duty as a Christian to fight abortion by any means necessary” (Risen 82). Bray’s decision to become involved in the anti-abortionist movement began when he was confronted by a woman who had had four abortions before the Roe versus Wade decision. Her story made it clear to Bray that “abortion was murder, a sin against God; she was a sinner seeking salvation; and now it was up to the faithful, the elect, to stamp out this evil. If the church failed to act, the church was guilty as well.” As Bray later stated, “It became impossible for me to continue to permit the tragedy to continue without direct intervention” (Risen 83).

Bray began with political involvement. In 1981, he went to a rally and met Thomas Spinks. They were both fundamentalists and members of the Cornerstone Assembly of God. In his writing, McVeigh stated that the “activist faith” of Evangelicals calls for a public presence of Christians, which would include protesting (McVeigh 1430). Bray convinced his church to help the Bowie Right to Life Committee to establish a local “crisis pregnancy center.” However, Bray and Spinks soon turned to more extreme measures to get their point across to the public. Their first clinic bombing occurred on January 14, 1984 at the Reproductive Care Clinic in Dover, Delaware. The clinic was completely destroyed by their homemade Molotov cocktails. By February 17, they had been reading up on more sophisticated weapons, and wired seven pipe bombs together, planting them against the outer wall of the Hillcrest Clinic in Norfolk, Virginia. Bray also left a sign there that read, “AOG – Army of God” (Risen 87). On May 19, Bray joined O’Keefe’s protests and started the Pro-Life Non-Violent Action Project campaign at a brand-new clinic in Gaithersburg, Maryland (Risen 89). He continued to give Spinks more clinic targets to hit. Bray was a highly religious man, and believed that the rules laid down by the Bible should be strictly followed. As McVeigh stated, “Biblical literalism and religious participation had a strong impact on the likelihood of participating in protest movements” (McVeigh 1426). Spinks once said, “Before God, we both felt committed that we had to do all we could to save as many of these children as we could, short of destroying the human lives who took human lives…in other words, it would be okay to destroy buildings…we viewed them as death camps. So we came to the agreement that it was okay to destroy these places as long as it was carefully carried out so that no human life would be lost in the process” (Risen 86).

The actions of these anti-abortion protestors were discussed in the media, including the New York Times. Research of the archives revealed that there were many newspaper articles that discussed the clinic bombings in Pensacola, Florida. However, the story that was discussed in these articles is not the same story discussed in Risen’s book, The Wrath of Angels. All of the newspaper articles are very factual. They tell what happened, when it happened, where it happened, and who was involved. However, they do not go very deeply into why these bombers were so fervent in their beliefs and statements. Risen’s book gives a more personal account of the activists and bombers, so that the reader can relate to them and understand why they did what they did. The articles do not show evidence of a strong bias, and many have quotes from both sides: the activists and the victims of the bombings. In one article about the Pensacola bombings, Mr. Pelham, who testified against Goldsby, stated, “If he saved one life, then what he had done was worthwhile. He felt that God’s law was what he had to follow, not man’s law” (NY Times, Jan 1, 1985). Other articles showed that not all of the religious activists condoned the bombings. The Reverend Lindall Ballenger of the First Assembly of God in Pensacola was quoted ass saying, “It’s easy to say, ‘God made me do it,’ but that’s a cop-out in my opinion. I’m not saying God can’t talk to people, but God doesn’t tell people to go out and bomb abortion clinics. Like it or not, abortion is legal, and blowing up a building is not. Our weapons are not bombs. All that does is take the issue away from us” (NY Times, 1985). Another article showed that people did condone the bombings. John Burt, an anti-abortionist said, “When the history of this period is written, it won’t be the pickets or the letter-writers who will be the heroes. It’s going to be the bombers” (NY Times, 1985). One article discussed the possibility that the bombers were mentally unstable. It said that they were claiming to suffer from “severe mental disorders” and were “borderline personalities capable of slipping in psychotic behavior” (NY Times, April 1985).

The photographs of this event also tell their own stories. Though not many photographs could be found that directly related to the Pensacola bombings, the photographs of the protest groups show the fervor that these activists had. Pictures relate to viewers differently than words do. Photos show emotion and speak to the viewer’s sentiments. They are vivid; the viewer cannot escape the reality of what the image is trying to say. An excellent example of the difference between images and words is the Silent Scream documentary. The Silent Scream was used as anti-abortionist propaganda. It depicted an abortion taking place, using an ultrasound for viewers to see the effects that an abortion has on the baby. The doctor who narrated this documentary explained the exact steps of an abortion, showing the viewer the tools that are used. It was scientifically based, yet it appealed to people’s emotions, and deterred many from supporting or having an abortion. This factually based documentary had a strong effect on the viewer, because it was the harsh reality. There was no “sugar-coating” what really happens during an abortion. The depiction was ugly, graphic, and highly disturbing. In the Abortion Power Point, many of the Protestant and Catholic views of abortion were stated and discussed. However, these statements about why abortion is wrong and should not be taken lightly did not have the same effect of actually seeing an abortion take place. In one reading, it stated, “aborting an unborn child destroys a unique creation which God has called specially into existence” (Abortion Power Point). However, viewing that actual destruction is what really makes the viewer/reader consider the issue more seriously. Images have a powerful impact on people. They can show the harsh realities of life, and speak to the viewer’s emotions. However, as seen from the activists, words can also have a lasting influence on people. Bray had the belief that the Bible was to be taken literally, which spurred him to use whatever means necessary to spread his beliefs to other people, and impose a change on society. What people see and read has an effect on their beliefs and standards. This has been seen in many culture wars throughout the decades, and will continue on as more controversial issues rise up.

Maxine R. Post 10

Maxine Rivera
Part I


At the beginnings of the anti-abortion movement the number of protesters was small and so the demonstrations were not very impressive or effective. There was emphasis on non-violence, so sit-ins were popular (as we know, sit-ins can be very effective, however a large number of people is generally required to make an impact.) As more people were drawn to the cause, some recruited, others searched for it, new personalities and ideas came to the movement. In Thomas and Risen's Wrath of Angels one such personality is discussed in chapter four. Michael Bray, the "father of violence" was not content to simply sit-in and pray for change, he wanted a more proactive approach, something that would grab attention and force people to deal with the issues. While he participated in peaceful protests, planned by O'Keefe, he wanted more. He found an outlet in Thomas Spinks. (p 83) Spinks was a fundamentalist who bombed abortion clinics to get his message across. Spinks worked alone, he and Bray became good friends, and while Bray did not go on bombing excursions with Spinks, he was extremely supportive. Bray and Spinks were not the only ones pushing the anti-abortion movement in a more violent direction, others like Joan Andrews and John Burt were pushing for a more violent approach prior to Pensacola as well. Andrews in fact, began her protesting career with the intention of breaking into an abortion clinic and damaging whatever she could, she was unsuccessful at first, but determination earned her success and a prison sentence. (p 190) John Burt was no stranger to violence, "a former Marine, former Klansmen," he owned a halfway house for girls where he employed corporal punishment. (p 195) He and Joan Andrews were arrested together at The Ladies Center Clinic in 1986, he was charged with assault among the other offenses. (p 201) While Andrews was in prison, new leaders like Randall Terry promoted violence in the movement, "street level tactics... trash clinic offices, throwing furniture and abortion equipment out clinic windows and down into the street." (p 207) Bombers were doing their part to gain publicity for the movement with events such as the Christmas bombings of 1984 by Matthew Goldsby and James Simmons (p 198) As time passed the protesters became more militant, the young leaders were going in a different direction, "When early leaders such as O'Keefe and Lee began to fade away, so did their theories about 'a peaceful presence.'" (p 192) This is not to say that their contributions were not important or impacting, the early, peaceful leaders are what sparked the movement, what drew the new, proactive leaders to demand change in their forceful way.

This change took place because people like Bray and Burt did not feel that the nonviolent approach was bringing enough attention to the cause. Bombings, violence, and arrests caught the attention of the press (at first only local and religious press, but eventually national) and demonstrators like Scheidler and Burt began to adopt "no press is bad press" and "as-long-as-the-spell-my-name-right" policies about the media. (p 200) This seemed to be an effective strategy because with press came attention to the issue, some people were completely unaware of the issue and therefore had not picked a side, the coverage, whether good or bad brought the war on abortion to the public eye and brought supporters to the cause.

Publicity was not the only factor that encouraged change from a small nonviolent movement to a national scale, more militant, movement, much of the change also came from guilt. Associate Pastor Steve Zepp was guilted into the movement by Shofner's radio attack on hypocritical pastors. (p 196) Bray charged Ericksen with sin for not acting out. (p 85) Basically protesters changed their methods for several reasons, one of which being that the old way wasn't getting results and this new, more violent approach gained attention and thus, supporters, and a second reason is that they felt duty-bound to forcefully oppose the murder of babies.
Part II

In God, Politics and Protest, Rory McVeigh and David Sikkink provide two ways that "religion can facilitate social protest." Each of these is evident in the anti-abortion movement and in Randall Terry's involvement in the movement. The first is that there must be a "perceived threat to deeply held religious beliefs or values" and the second is that "specific religious beliefs that characterize life as a struggle between forces of good and evil may carry over to acceptance of the contentious tactics of protest." (p 1427) Terry being a Christian believed murder was wrong, he also believed abortion was the murder of a baby, thus abortion was wrong. The legalization of abortion was essentially the legalization of murder of the innocent, this is a clear example of evil. So, according to McVeigh and Sikkink, Terry meets the two main requirements for someone who has been inspired to participate in social protest by religion. In Wrath, Thomas and Risen explain that the Evangelical Church was "booming" at the time Terry proposed action, and why Terry figured that fundamentalists would be a good group to reach out to. (p 206) "The 'activist faith' of evangelicals calls for a public presence of Christians in all aspects of life, including protest." (God, Politics, and Protest, 1430) Not only does the faith support taking action against evils in "all aspects of life," the fundamentalist ministers are not tied to the hierarchy of the Catholic Church. Their independence makes them ideal, they could bring their "flock" with them, without checking with bishops, cardinals, the Pope, etc. to see if participation was okay. (Wrath 206)


Part III


69 More Opponents Of Abortion Jailed In Atlanta Protests
http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?res=940DE1D61F39F934A3575BC0A96E948260

CLINIC BOMB TRIAL TOLD OF DISORDERS



In comparison with Thoman and Risen's summaries of the anti-abortion events, the authors of these two articles were very removed. In Wrath of Angels Risen and Thomas seemed to present the people involved in the movement as heroes, not that they necessarily agreed with every one of their moves, but that they acknowledged that there was a kind of honor in fighting for what you believe in. In the Times articles above, the tone is nonpartisan, they simply relate the facts of the situations. In the first article they tell of a demonstration protesting abortion and Joan Andrew's imprisonment. Randall Terry was among the arrested, the author provides quotes, but no personal opinion. The same holds true for the second article which tells of the trial of Goldsby and Simmons and their respective partners. Each was diagnosed with mental disorders, at the end of the article, the author tells of how Miss Wiggins sobbed as she insisted that she was unaware of the plan, but there is no noticeable tone of pity. The reason for this lack of opinionated writing in the newspaper is that the New York Times is a fairly well known, widely read paper. The editors probably would not want their articles to seem like they were taking a side and risk losing customers or causing even more controversy.

Photos, on the other hand, need not worry about proper wording to keep customers. Photos tell things the way they are, without bias (or so we are to believe.) The photo above is propaganda for the anti-abortion cause. The image of the baby's unattached head above is very powerful, more powerful than an unopinionated article in a widely read newspaper, or a homemade sign that reads "STOP ABORTION NOW!!!" The photograph makes abortion seem real, it is not an abstract concept, it is not a way to solve a problem, it is the "destruction" of a life, to quote Bernard Nathanson in The Silent Scream. Text is undoubtedly very powerful, but in this particular instance, and for the purposes of the Pro Life movement, images hold even more power. The film The Silent Scream made me nauseous, and I imagine it had similar affect on others. I could have read about the process of abortion, but i could easily wipe words from my memory, the image will not go as easily. I am personally Pro Choice, but the film did make me think, and even more importantly, feel.



Jenn Post 10

Jenn Shea

Question One

Initially, anti-abortion movements focused mainly on quiet lobbying and the formation of pro-life groups. These groups consisted of individuals who were morally opposed to the destruction of the potential for human life and participated in non-violent forms of protest including sit-ins, picketing, and campaigning. Shortly after the Roe v. Wade case, a group of Catholics formed right-to-life groups: “The NCCB quietly asked local bishops to recruit Catholic volunteers to set up local anti-abortion organizations, and the national group retained a political consultant to support these new ‘right-to-life’ organizations. These state groups later formed the backbone of the mainstream anti-abortion movement when they united under the umbrella of the National Right to Life Committee, founded by the American bishops in 1972” (Risen 19). Even Michael Bray, who is responsible for aiding several clinic bombings, showed some form of nonviolent protest as an effective means to attract media attention and increase public awareness at the Wheaton clinic on November 17, 1984: “Outside the Wheaton clinic, Michael Bray sat down with his young son in his arms, waiting quietly for the police to take him away. He offered a perfect image of nonviolent civil disobedience, one that was quickly captured by local television cameras and broadcast on that evening’s newscasts” (92). However, that same clinic was then bombed the next day. Anti-abortion advocates were becoming more and more hungry for effective action, and in seeing that peaceful sit-ins were not ending abortion, even nonviolent protestors began resorting to violent means or justifying those who did. For example, O’Keefe’s Pro-Life Non-Violent Action Project was sabotaged by other anti-abortion bombers who blew up the clinic where he had organized a non-violent sit-in the day before. “‘Yes, it [the bombing] is just,’ O’Keefe told the Washington Post hours after the bombing. ‘Is it prudent? No. [But] it is just to respond to violence against people by destroying property. Human life is far more valuable than property. Pro-lifers are going to act….The question is what shape will the action take’” (94). After that, when the idea of civil disobedience was called upon as a course of action, O’Keefe failed to step up to lead, and when he did schedule more sit-ins, they were unsuccessful due to his tarnished reputation: “O’Keefe tried to stage more sit-ins, but his Washington civil disobedience campaign never recovered from its association with Bray, and it soon faded away” (99). Because of this, violent means became prominent, especially in Pensacola, Florida. In general, individuals sought more than just preaching the immorality of abortion and wanted to make a stronger statement by acting. A man by the name of Randall Terry also began to transform the means of anti-abortion protest, which brought concern from National Right to Life leaders, as they saw his impulsivity as dangerous to the cause: “In a speech in Pensacola’s Seville Square, Terry called on his fellow activists to storm abortion clinics; solder shut elevators and blockade doors so that police could not reach them; and completely trash clinic offices, throwing furniture and abortion equipment out clinic windows and down into the street…National Right to Life leaders immediately saw that if Terry carried out his radical tactics on a nationwide scale, he would bring the full weight of the government down on the activists and perhaps do as much to cloud the reputation of the entire anti-abortion movement as had earlier clinic bombings and arsons” (207). Silent protest was no longer sufficient for Reverend David Shofner, a pastor of West Pensacola Baptist Church: “Frustrated that so few other fundamentalist Protestants were joining, Shofner went on a local Christian radio station to criticize local pastors who ‘preach about abortion in church but don’t do anything outside the pulpit’” (196). Joan Andrews was one of the most recognized irrational and destructive protesters in Pensacola. She went as far as to spread noxious liquids, damaged abortion equipment, and when sent to prison, took on a vow of noncooperation within the prison system to answer “God’s calling.” The most appalling bombings occurred in Pensacola on Christmas 1984 and clearly demonstrated that civil disobedience was taking a backseat to violence, which was gaining far more attention than sit-ins had. As Risen notes, “The Christmas bombing spree put Pensacola on the abortion map. The three bombings, which occurred within minutes of each other between 3 and 4 A.M. on Christmas morning, 1984, were by far the most spectacular acts of anti-abortion violence yet staged. Isolated acts of arson and vandalism had been occurring for years at clinics, but they had never generated this sort of sustained, national press attention…anti-abortion activism had taken a sudden turn to extremism. President Reagan was forced to issue a statement denouncing the bombings” (197-198). Thus, the negative attention certain pro-life initiatives began receiving made civil disobedience pointless, as individuals did not want to listen to activists who believed that violence and destruction solved problems. Activists saw that the more violence and destruction they took part in, the more their anti-abortion position became broadcast and publicized. Their message began spreading faster the more irrational their actions became. As Hand said, “‘Blowing up clinics only hardens hearts’” (94). Because of this, activists resorted to more severe means to get their anti-abortion sentiments across.

Question Two

In their article “God, Politics, and Protest,” McVeigh and Sikkink discuss, test, and analyze three different reasons as to why Protestants approve of “contentious actions.” They discuss that traditionally, Protestants avoid tension and conflict and instead express their religious tendencies at a more tranquil level: “Mainline Protestants have developed religious traditions that support a quiet, individual expression of their religious faith in public life. Similarly, liberal Protestants construct a relatively low degree of tension between religious faith and the surrounding social and cultural environment, which may lead to less support for contentious politics as an expression of their religious faith” (1430). They note that despite this traditional behavior of Protestant expression, these individuals are becoming more and more likely to get involved with protest and conflict concerning their religious values: “…a perceived threat to deeply held religious beliefs or values may provide an incentive to participate in social protest. In addition, specific religious beliefs that characterize life as a struggle between forces of good and evil may carry over to acceptance of the contentious tactics of protests” (1427). One theory for this participation in protest is the cultural defense theory, which involves when individuals’ religious values are challenged, and thus the individuals feel obligated to defend these values, even if such defense means involvement in contentious behavior: “The basic argument of cultural defense theory is that moral reform movements emerge in response to a challenge to deeply held beliefs and values that are rooted in the participants’ religion…participants in a moral reform movement are acting defensively in an effort to preserve a moral order that provides meaning for their lives…We argue that those who do perceive that their religious values are being threatened are likely to view the use of contentious tactics as a legitimate defensive strategy” (1431). McVeigh and Sikkink also suggest in their analysis that individuals may sometimes feel that they should carry out God’s will. When confronted by something sinful, these individuals feel it is their duty to carry out God’s punishment themselves. In this way, such individuals are God’s messengers and thus their actions are justified because God is the driving force behind their behaviors: “When God is represented as in radical conflict with humanity and human history, we expect that contentious tactics in the public square will be seen as a legitimate expression of carrying out God’s work in the world…Some scholars have noted that a belief in human sinfulness promotes support for corporal punishment…The ‘tough love’ of God’s dealing with sin becomes the frame that justifies parallel contentious tactics for believers in a sinful world” (1432-1433). Finally, McVeigh and Sikkink found that by being involved in an organized church setting, individuals are more likely to be exposed to organized protest movements because such movements target large and already organized institutions: “Participation in religious activities can also increase an individual’s exposure to social movement activists and recruiters. Organized religion provides a ripe target for activists practicing bloc recruitment” (1433).

Randall Terry demonstrates McVeigh and Sikkink’s theory that individuals are driven to partake in protest and other contentious actions because they believe they are acting on the word of God. He also demonstrates a defense of values, as he recites passages from the Bible saying that abortion was condemned by god: “‘Abortion…is an attack on the Word of God and ultimately on the kingdom and Church of God…Abortion is the shedding of innocent blood, which God condemns and God commands His people to rise in defense of those who cannot defend themselves” (249). As described by Risen and Thomas, Terry attempted to “translate the language of social protest into the language of Protestant fundamentalism” (249). In doing so, Randall insisted that Project life was Christ centered and its goals included “sharing the love of God with young women and their boyfriends/husbands, and telling them the truth about themselves and their babies…We proclaim what God’s Word says concerning life in the womb, and what a Christian’s responsibility is in this Holocaust (249). In addition, Pierce Creek’s Pastor Dan Little proclaimed Terry as “God’s chosen leader in the fight against abortion” (251).

Question Three

In the book, Risen and Thomas give very little text about the impact of the film The Silent Scream by Dr. Bernard Nathanson. It simply states that the film “was highlighted by traumatic footage of an ultrasound examination conducted during an abortion. During the mid-1980s, The Silent Scream became the anti-abortion movement’s single most successful piece of propaganda and one of its most effective recruiting tools” (198). The book fails to mention that it was also recognized as one very controversial film in that it portrayed misleading information. In both of the New York Times articles I found, one from January 25, 1985 titled “Debate on Abortion Focuses on Graphic Film,” and the other from March 11, 1985 titled “A False ‘Scream,’” individuals claim that there is no evidence that a fetus has the capability of reacting aggressively to intrusion or that it is capable of struggling. Instead, according to Dr. Jenniger Niebyl in the “A False ‘Scream’” article, “‘The fetus, at this gestational age, is really exhibiting strictly reflex activity’” (A18). At that stage, according to another doctor, the fetus is not be able to perceive pain or process information because the cortex is not developed in the brain. In the “Debate on Abortion” article, Dr. Nathanson defends his statements in the film and insists that even without the cortex, the fetus feels pain, stating, “‘Pain is a reflex. It is not an intellectual exercise.’ The fetus, he said, ‘is being stuck and stalked, and responds reflexively as any animal would when exposed to pain’” (NYT). Whether or not the fetus actually does feel pain, the images seen in this film are nonetheless very disturbing. The link below is for a clip in the film showing the aborted fetuses outside of the womb, and the supposed mouth in the form of a scream. Below, the image on the left shows the aborted fetuses in containers, while the right photo is a still of the “silent scream,” but is very difficult to see in ultrasound form. The text in the book does not nearly describe the reaction the film actually received, nor does it portray very strongly the types of images in the film and how disturbing they are. The photographs of the aborted fetuses are almost indescribable in how uncomfortable and heart-wrenching they are, and Risen and Thomas’ use of “traumatic” does not seem sufficient. The two New York Times articles, although they make a good point about the evidential non-existence of the cortex, which is the part of the brain the sends and receives neurotransmitters for pain, still cannot compete with the images of fetuses discarded into containers or a fetus being sucked out of a woman’s womb. In the images, the message of torture and the destruction of the potential for life can be seen, while in the text such issues are simply a topic of debate or are understated and lightly touched upon. Finally, in the film The Silent Scream, even if one does not listen to the man’s explanation of what is happening, the scenes with showing the woman on the exam table during the actual abortion procedure and the images mixed in of aborted fetuses say enough. Even if a viewer does not wish to hear the arguably propagandist and sensationalized preaching of Dr. Nathanson, the images are still enough to probably make even the most extreme pro-choice advocate a little uncomfortable. With rhetoric, one can stop listening at any time and close out another’s opinions in disbelief; with images, one simple viewing of an aborted fetus leaves a lasting impression on the mind, no matter how tight one tries close his or her eyes to try to block the image out afterward.

Part 4 of Movie:

http://www.silentscream.org/video/SScream%20English/SilentSc_Eng_4.mov





Still Images from
http://www.abortiontv.com/Movies/silentscream.htm

Tuesday, November 6, 2007

etibbetts post 10

Erica Tibbetts

Question #1: How did the anti-abortion movement evolve from the first reaction to Roe Vs. Wade until Pensacola? Why did this escalation take place? How and why did the protestors change their approach?

The anti-abortion movement started with non-violent, sit-ins and protests that aimed to raise attention to the movement and the leaders, but no to harm anyone or do damage. Organizations such as Pro-Life Non-Violent Action Project led by Scheidler, John O’Keefe and Harry Hand, aimed at alerting the public of the “crimes and sins” they perceived to be occurring. O’Keefe staged sit ins- his crowning moment coming on November 17th 1984 when, “forty-six people, including seventeen Catholic and Protestant members of the clergy were arrested, which at the time was the largest number of arrests for any one anti-abortion event” (91). O’Keefe had been active since the 1970’s and he never strayed from this sort of protest.

Michael Bray pretended to be a part John O’Keefe’s movement, acting in many of his sit-ins and adding his fervor to PNAP. However, while he was doing this he was also advising Thomas Spinks. The two began bombing abortion clinics in January, 1984, under the auspices of AOG, Army of God.

Bray said of himself and Spinks, “Before God, we both felt committed that we had to do all we could to save as many of these children as we could, short of destroying the human lives who took human lives” (86). After the first two bombings Bray had Spinks act alone, in order to keep himself distanced from the physical action of bombing. However, he still advised Spinks on where to bomb, and helped him store the materials he used.

Meanwhile he took a bigger role in PNAP. So, it was Bray himself he sort of started the downfall of non-violent anti-abortion movements in the north. After the November 17th success, in which Bray did not participate, he heard about the arrests made and is recorded to have said, “Getting arrested. That sounds like something we should do” (88). When Spinks was caught, after bombing a site that PNAP had recently picketed, O’Keefe’s movement suffered a blow. Because O’Keefe could not and did not distance himself sufficiently from the bombings, he alienated certain members of the movement who were not interested in violence. About the bombings, O’Keefe said, “It is just to respond to violence against people by destroying property. Human life is far more valuable than property. Pro-lifers are going to act… The question is what shape will action take. (94)

After Brays’ arrest and incarceration, and O’Keefe’s wishy washy response, the PNAP movement struggled to make any more important anti-abortion actions.

About the same time as this was going on, however; Joan Andrews was starting her rise to stardom. She differed from the above mentioned activists in that she was a Catholic and they were Protestants, and the anti-abortion problem was traditionally viewed as a Catholic one, due to that sects idea of the wrongs of contraception, etc. Her actions, arrest, and behavior while in jail turned her into a martyr, appreciated by all religious activists, no matter their affiliation. While O’Keefe strayed away from damaging any property, and Bray headed towards the other extreme in his choice to blow things up, Andrews seemed to provide a sort of middle ground. Her actions consisted of filling abortion clinic door locks with super glue and damaging equipment (she was arrested for the latter). During her time in court and in jail, Andrews refused to do anything of her own volition, making police officers and jail guards carry her from place to place. This kind of behavior gained her a huge following and forwarded the message and prestige of the anti-abortion movement in ways that almost no other occurrence could have She was what Risen and Thomas call, “the movement’s first full-time intinerant protestor”(192).

One of the most interesting things about Andrews was her ability to unite the Protestant and Catholic religion: “It is one of the great ironies of the anti-abortion cause that fundamentalist Protestants, who until then had steered clear of anti-abortion activism in part because of their antipathy toward all things Catholic were finally mobilized by the plight of a woman who was feverishly Catholics: a woman who gripped her rosary beads at each moment of crisis, who felt the greatest punishment she could endure in prison was to be denied attendance at Catholics Mass” (188). Even while she was endlessly pacing her jail cell, she was strenthgening the bonds between fellow protestors.

After Andrews, Cindy and Randy Terry took center stage. They began picketing together with little more than their own persons and a few anti-abortion posters outside of Southern Tier abortion clinic in Binghamton. The authors mention an interesting statistic “In 1973 more than half of all abortions were performed in hospitals: by 1988, 86 percent of all abortions were being performed in freestanding clinics like southern tier and only 10 percent in hospitals” (244). The importance of this statistic is that it caused more demonstrators like the Terry’s to feel compelled to picket and protest outside of abortion clinics, because they were easier and more important targets. After being frustrated by very few successful attempt at convincing women to reconsider their decisions to abort, Randy Terry managed to enlist the help of Pastor Dan Little and his congregation. With this added support he founded “Project Life”- a non-profit organization that would help him fund his new obsession with picketing and protesting. The author’s state that Terry had a “heavy reliance on Evangelical rhetoric and biblical references” which helped attract religious groups and individuals (249).

As he became more confident and better supported, Terry moved on to bigger projects, naming his organization “Operation Rescue”. He managed to organize a boycott of the entire shopping center in which Southern Tier was located, he began locking himself and his followers into rooms, chaining himself to equipment, and basically becoming more and more invasive and confident with his tactics. After being arrested, he reveled in the media: “Their sit-in had generated more news coverage than Terry could have ever imagined, and he quickly became convinced that civil disobedience is the only path to successful protest in modern America” (254). After this he was arrested multiple times and saw his fame rise within the anti-abortion movement. He attended many meetings where Catholics and evangelists united, saying at one point, “For the first time I was at a pro-life meeting where I was no the token Protestant’ (259).

After garnering even more support he moved onto to mass protest organization. He first hit Cherry Hill, New Jersey, after being foiled a his attempt to get at Philadelphia clinics. He and about 400 protestors officially kept the clinic from operating until after 4 p.m. and only 210 of the protestors were arrested (263). After this he moved on to New York City, where he hit 3 different sites in the span of a week, and eventually angering the local police to the point where they started dragging protestors away from the site. He eventually overstepped his own boundaries and grew too big for his boots, becoming overstretched and ineffective.

After Terry and the peak of non-violent yet still highly invasive anti-abortion tactics, the anti-abortion killing sprees began. It started with Michael Griffin’s slaying of David Gunn, an act that he called “Providence”; “I knew he was getting ready to kill children that day. I asked the Lord what he wanted me to do. And he told me to tell him that he had one more chance” (339). Griffin shot Gunn three times, in the back and did it under the auspices of the following bible verse, ‘Whosoever sheds man’s blood, by his blood shall be shed” (340). After this, Shelley Shannon went on an anti-abortion rampage, detonating bombs all over the country and ending her spree in the shooting of George Tiller. While she didn’t succeed in killing him, she was tried and convicted of attempted murder. She confessed immediately to the crime, saying “If there ever was a justifiable homicide, that would have been it” (356). And this was exactly the motivation that spurred Shannon and the rest of the killers. They all thought they were doing the right thing in stopping what they perceived to be “murder”. None of them stopped to think of the consequences of the murder they themselves were committing, and all of them seemed to think they had God’s will on their side. Risen and Thomas write that, “Shannon’s transformation from a housewife participating in mainstream protest to a radical member of a new violent underground was, in many ways, a metaphor for the decline and fall of the anti-abortion movement itself”(349). She went from being committed and passionate, a great asset to the cause because she had few ties or restrictions, to becoming a great liability because of her over-zealousness and borderline mental breakdown. The killings that took the lives of not just doctors who performed abortions (Gunn, Britton, Tiller) but also patients, people aiding the doctors, and patients, turned popular opinion, the media and the government against the cause. With a liberal President in office, the anti-abortion lobbyists lost ground and the Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act was passed, “making it a federal crime to block access to clinics or to commit acts aimed at denying a woman access to an abortion” (357). With this legislation, the lack of any sort of public support, and the conflict within the anti-abortion groups themselves over the issue of violence, the movement basically fell apart.



Question #2: McVeigh and Sikkink’s article argues that certain factors make Protestants approve of “contentious actions.” Apply their analysis to one of the individuals you have reads about in Risen and Thomas: Michael Bray, Joan Andrews, Randall Terry, Michael Griffin, or Paul Hill.
McVeigh and SIkkink argue that the single greatest factor leading Protestants to protest is their approval of “contentious action” however; after this first indicator, they are a little hazy on what exactly makes them approve or what (after their approval has been affirmed) makes them actually participate. A few factors such as a single mindedness about the kind of morality people should follow, the inherent sinfulness of humans, the idea of a God at odds with humanity, and participation in church related activities.

The authors mention that the main difference between being politically active by voting or functioning within approve, conventional foundations, and being politically active by protesting is “the contentious and disruptive nature of protest” (1426). People have to feel strongly enough about something, and have to feel sufficiently dissatisfied with the political framework in pace, in order to engage in protest type behavior. In quoting an earlier study, the authors point out that “Biblical Literalism and religious participation had a strong impact on the likelihood of participating in protest movements in the 1960’s” (1426).

The main things the authors are looking at are the connection between “a perceived threat to deeply held religious beliefs or values” and “specific religious beliefs that characterize life as a struggle between the forces of good and evil” (1427). In both cases, the correlation is being predicted to be positive. If people have deep seated beliefs and do not see these beliefs mirrored in the behavior of society, then they are more like to act; just as if they feel there is a fundamental struggle going on, and it is their responsibility to act.

Another thing McVeigh and Sikkink mention is the idea of “grievance interpretation”. Religion gives people a lens through which to view the world and the world’s slights. It also give people a group in which to gather support or be rallied towards a certain end. “Before collective protest can occur, a group must define the situation as one that can and should be addressed through collective action. Another important point that McVeigh and Sikkink mention is that, “A religion’s system of collective beliefs can be drawn upon to construct a worldview that legitimizes the use of contentious tactics” (1433)
The authors also mention the difference between different types of Protestant religion, saying that, “Fundamentalsits, for example, have developed countercultural religious netweorks, [which] de-emphasize the importance of bringing about social and political change” (1430). While evangelical groups are much more likely to participate and try to distance themselves from the perceived apathy of the fundamentalist mindset.

Also discussed is the idea of “moral absolutism” and a kind of “God vs. the world” mentality. If a relgion stresses the fact that modern culture is sinful and individuals tend to go against the will of God, then a member of this religion is going to feel at odds with society and be more likely to protest (1432).

There is basically a link between the vehemence with which a group feels destined to protect a certain value, and an individual’s link to this group, and protest. When a person feels they can relate with Protestant views, especially as an evangelical, and this person attends church or meetings often, then he or she is more likely to participate in some form of protest.

In the case of a person like Joan Andrews, who while not a Protestant, was a fervent Catholic religion was a foundation of life, a reason for being, something to lead ones life by, and something to drive one’s passion. She grew up in a home with lots of siblings, and was shown the sanctity of life when her mother had a miscarriage and the fetus was christened and buried. She identified with everything Catholic and saw abortion as an evil that God would disapprove of and that was as bad or worse than the murder of any other human being. She found an anger in herself that was bred by her identification as a Catholic. And because she had little else to tie her down, no money, family, job, she was able to dedicate herself to the movement. She threw herself whole-heartedly into this movement because she felt no apprehension about protesting, vandalizing, or being arrested. To her, these things were insignificant compared to the wrongs of abortion.

The Catholic religion itself is very clear in its opposition to abortion. Thus, it provides a very clear lens through which Andrews could view the act, and through which she could also see herself as responsible for fighting against the perceived evil.


Question #3: Using The New York Times,* find articles relating to a specific event that you read about in Risen and Thomas and examine how the event was portrayed in the Times versus how Risen and Thomas interpret it. What if any differences do you see? How would you explain them? Using a Google Image search find photographs of these events. Again compare the written description to the images you discover. Do you find different messages imbedded in the text and images? If so, how do you explain it?

Abortions, Bibles and Bullets, And the Making of a Militant

By DIRK JOHNSONSpecial to The New York Times

New York Times (1857-Current file); Aug 28, 1993; ProQuest Historical Newspapers The New York Times (1851 - 2004)

pg. 1

In the case of Shelly Shannon, the Risen book portrayed her as a fanatic, a zealot, someone who took her daughter along to protests and got her arrested, someone who took her husband’s car while he was out of town, spent his money, did little but fight against the perceived evil of abortion. The book discusses her background, her marriage, her children, her married life, her family, her need to homeschool her children to protect their beliefs, etc. The book makes her seem like a full person, if deeply obsessed. Meanwhile, in the article I found on the New York Times site, she merely seems crazy. The tone is almost ironic; as if pointing to the moral dilemma that is posed by someone who kills for the sake of saving lives. The article has none of the bibliographical elements, none of the things that make Shannon whole, interesting and compelling. While in Risen, the reader can almost (almost) identify with the woman’s dedication, her desire to protect what she saw as innocent lives, in the article, the absurdity of the situation, the possible conspiracy theory, the plight of the injured doctor are stressed, and the woman is not sympathetic at all.

The title of the article, “Abortions, Bibles and Bullets, And the Making of a Militant” sets the tone immediately. There is no softening of the crime, no rationalizing, just this bold statement about violence and a contentious subject. A friend of Shelley’s tells the journalist that Shannon supported the recent, earlier killing of an abortion doctor. There is no defense of her character, just statements about her bail charge, where she is being held and what she did. Similar to Risen, Dirk (the author of the article) compares Shannon’s rise to violence with the changing attitude among all anti-abortion groups. She is described as the radical, the outlier, the one who signifies a change in the movement, and the one who is a problem with in it. The article describes her reaction to hearing about the killing of Gunn by Griffin. She thought it was the correct thing to do, and saw nothing wrong with murdering abortion doctors. She is also described as writing letters to those who were imprisoned as part of the invasive anti-abortion protests. All in all the article does not portray as complete a picture as does the Risen book, and the description of her and her actions is much more biased than in the book. This discrepancy probably arises for a number of reasons. Mainly, Risen has more space to describe Shannon, whereas Dirk has 2 pages, Risen has half a chapter. And, Risen seems given to a journalistic description of details, background, and explanation that Dirk cannot go into. Also, while Risen is by no means unbiased, he does attempt to show both sides of each anti-abortion activist. While Dirk attempts to show some of the frustration facing the anti-abortion movement, he cannot capture the full scope of the obstacle and problems these activists faced in trying to get their message across. Risen does capture this progression, and adding Shannon as the final step in the escalation towards violence makes sense to the reader of a full book, whereas in the article, the same progression is not clear.
As for images, I found on a “court tv website” http://www.courttv.com/onair/shows/mugshots/indepth/shannon/. It has a composite picture of Shannon before the crime, a picture of the injured doctor being administered oxygen by paramedics, some anti-abortion signs, and then a mug shot of Shannon in prison. The image is a mixture of many different ideas. The doctor’s face, in the oxygen mask is probably the most telling, although it does compete with the text in the anti-abortion signs to catch the viewer’s eye. The text helps keep the image from entirely condemning Shannon as just another crazy, unjustified killer, but it is also an aggressive element that may or may not create a softer portrayal of her. It reads, “How old does a child have to be before you defend her with force?” This message is exactly what Shannon stands for within the anti-abortion movement. She is at the tipping point, where non-violent protest turned into frustrated, last ditch efforts, and murder. The mug shot is grainy and dull, making her look every part the killer. So, while the image is not entirely condemning it is not very supportive of Shannon.


Monday, November 5, 2007

Amanda D. Post # 10

  1. Overall, the anti-abortion movement shifted from a focus on non-violent civil disobedience to violent extremism, especially as the core protesting organizations changed. John O’Keefe and the earlier Catholic protesters believed in a “merciful. . . Christ” (Risen and Thomas 78) and thus pursued and encouraged peaceful protest. However, when intensely religious Protestant fundamentalists such as Michael Bray began to make abortion into a fundamentalist issue, they approached it from the standpoint of believing in predestination and an “angry…wrathful Son of God” (Risen and Thomas 78). As the fundamentalists began joining the peaceful clinic sit-ins of civil disobedience protest organizations such as the Pro-Life Non-Violent Action Project, a rift in ideas formed. Many fundamentalists began to crave and take an aggressive approach toward stopping abortion, as they soon felt that sit-ins and disobedience were not doing enough to bring God’s judgment and justice upon the sinful “murderers” who got or gave abortions. Their goals became more “ambitious and brazen” (Risen and Thomas 90) and their tactics became more militant and violent, including clinic chain-ins and vandalism (including lock-gluing), spreading noxious fumes within the building, clinic bombings, and eventually, the shooting of abortion doctors. As peaceful tactics became overshadowed by militant and violent ones, new anti-abortion leaders took over, generally without permission, as spokespeople for the organizations founded by the peaceful protest leaders. This understandably caused more difficulty for the “public and media” in telling the “difference between” peaceful protesters and the increasing base of radical and violent protesters (Risen and Thomas 94). On top of this, the only media attention that was given to the anti-abortion movement was when a radical protester used showy and violent tactics that caused her or his arrest and/or the destruction of property or a human life. Therefore, this could be one of the factors that caused the movement to morph into violence and extremism, where no attention would be given to it otherwise. Especially after witnessing the events of Joan Andrews in Pensacola and her disobedience while in prison, people became more daring and extreme in their protesting of abortion and fundamentalists and Catholics found common ground (Risen and Thomas 188). Her actions and publicized arrest encouraged others such as John Burt, Michael Griffin, and Rachelle Shannon to make a real impact and to act violently against all who were involved in the abortion process. This marked the changing face of the anti-abortion movement into a radical and violent force which called for public attention. With the “martyrization” of violent protesters and the attention that came to be paid to violent and destructive acts, the number of extremist protesters and organizations of the movement, acting on what they deemed to be “God’s will” or “God’s justice” on earth, grew and came to the foreground, confusing public opinion of the anti-abortion movement between the peaceful and non-violent groups that used to dominate the scene and the violent, extremist groups that pulled down and destroyed the movement.

  1. McVeigh and Sikkink seem to have found through their survey data that religious identity, “a lot” of church and some protest participation, and the belief in a tense relationship between God and the world including emphasis on the idea that humans are sinners, are factors that make one more likely to accept “contentious tactics” in protest acts than other Christians (McVeigh and Sikkink 1449). Michael Griffin happens to posses a number of these characteristics that McVeigh and Sikkink have connected to the acceptance of “contentious actions.” At one point in his life, Griffin became deeply associated with the Brownsville Assembly of God, a church which was instrumental in the “fundamentalist revival” (Risen and Thomas 340-341), and later became a part of John Burt’s fundamentalist church, Whitfield Assembly of God (Risen and Thomas 343). This particular religious identification (the fundamentalist and evangelical) is the one that, statistically, is the most likely to be related to cases of people who approve of such “contentious tactics,” (McVeigh and Sikkink 1449) and Griffin obviously did, having murdered abortion doctor David Gunn. Interestingly, though, other factors appear to have swayed Griffin into violent protest actions. He was mentally/emotionally unstable to begin with, having allegedly abused his wife and tried to kidnap his children from her custody (Risen and Thomas 341). This and his response to the power of anti-abortion images and propaganda are also key factors unrelated to any data gathered in the McVeigh and Sikkink survey that would no doubt influence his attitude toward “contentious” behavior and violence. After watching the “graphic” anti-abortion film The Hard Truth, Griffin was so affected that he felt shocked into the realization of what abortion really was and that he should do something to prevent it, as God would want (Risen and Thomas 341). Also, Griffin participated in church activities, one of the other characteristics that McVeigh and Sikkink link to the approval of “contentious actions.” Griffin sat in the front row during services and addressed the congregation to ask for a prayer request for the soul of David Gunn, to get him to “stop killing babies” (Risen and Thomas 343). While this is not intense involvement in a church activity, it certainly reflects Griffin’s active participation in the church, which shows his willingness to take charge and act on his thoughts and beliefs, as one would have to in order to stand during a service and make such a direct statement in request. Through his fundamentalist beliefs in a wrathful and angry God who is pitted against the sinful world, the influence of powerful anti-abortion propaganda films and images, aggressive church participation, and the influence of a spiritual leader such as John Burt, whose protest participation was great and violent (and perhaps a bit of mental instability), Michael Griffin possesses the characteristics that McVeigh and Sikkink found from their survey to be connected to the approval by a Protestant to “contentious tactics” in protest of an issue, here the issue being anti-abortion activism. So violent and publicly attention-drawing was Griffin’s murder of David Gunn that he is pinned with “flushing the extremist fringe” of the anti-abortion movement “out into the open” and destroying all “credibility or influence” of the movement through nonviolent means (Risen and Thomas 344).

  1. The Risen and Thomas interpretation of the June and December bombings of the Ladies Center by Matthew Goldsby and James Simmons details more of the religious justification for and reasons as to why the men felt as if they needed to bomb the Center. It explains from a more personal standpoint than the Times articles do the background stories of the young men and makes it out to be more sympathetic than the articles. For instance, the book explains how the men felt “badly shaken” after watching the anti-abortion film The Silent Scream and how it made them believe that God had called them to act (Risen and Thomas 198). On the other hand, one Times article almost seems to mock the men while making them appear cocky, apathetic and emotionless, and even a bit unintelligent. This could be attributed to the fact that the book is not written to report a news story, as the Times is, but rather can take the time to weave a more personal account of the event and those responsible for it. Also in Risen and Thomas’s interpretation, the event itself seems rather un-shocking and even inferior to similar actions made by others, whereas in the Times articles, the events are made to seem much more important and on a larger scale than the authors of the book make it appear. The reasons for this could be due to the fact that the book accounts the progression and history of the anti-abortion cause, including what could be considered more serious and important and better-executed and effective in the overall history of the movement, descriptions that the Goldsby-Simmons case do not warrant when compared to the other events Risen and Thomas describe. Furthermore, a newspaper such as the Times would write about something small as if it was great and important in order to catch the attention of the reader and get him or her to adopt a certain attitude or opinion towards the event, and that seems as if this may have happened in the case of the coverage of the Goldsby-Simmons bombings. Plus, the anti-abortion movement has yet to reach its most violent and extreme form, so when reading the Risen and Thomas book there is already prior knowledge of events which are far greater and more significant than the one mentioned here, a foresight that those reporting as the event occurs have not. The Risen and Thomas text make the bombings out to be a dramatic event, but not one that warrants too much attention and not overly important when considering the history of the movement and the greater violence to come, while the Times articles make it out to be a greater deal than perhaps it really was in hindsight, making the men involved out to be just short of domestic terrorists.

Though I looked extensively on multiple databases, I could find no photograph from or relating to the Goldsby and Simmons bombings of the Ladies Center or of the other abortion providers. However, based on many of the images of other protests outside of the Ladies Center, particularly and overwhelmingly of Paul Hill, it can be argued that the images do hold more power over the viewer than the texts of both Risen and Thomas and the Times. The messages of these photographs do not seem to be any different from the text, especially since they are carefully selected to match the feeling of the texts which they usually accompany, but they can contribute a visual element that is easier for one to respond to and in a quicker time, be that response positive or negative. In the case of many of the Paul Hill photographs, Hill is viewed in an almost sympathetic light, sometimes with his family, sometimes protesting and promoting what he knows to be right, and other times defending his beliefs from jail, often with quotes that explain how he looks at his execution positively because it will bring him back to his God. In general comparison, the written descriptions in the Risen and Thomas book mirror some of these sentiments of occasional sympathy and justification for the actions made while those in the Times (or probably any other newspaper) will stick with facts but spin them to support whichever view the reporter personally (or editorial staff) has toward the event, presenting a bias when compared to the book, which tends not to support one side over the other but rather leaves the decision up to the reader.