Wednesday, October 3, 2007

Amy I

Amy Iarrobino
Post 6
Both Devereaux and Brand address the issue of the images presented by film. Devereaux is much more in-depth in supporting her argument and providing examples as Brand’s piece is merely an introduction. Brand contends that in film “the universal subject is historically situated (masculine, patriarchal, imperialistic)” (Brand, 8). Devereaux agrees by addressing the claims that “in cinema the gaze is male, and that the cinematic text is a male text” (Devereaux, 126). Although Devereaux does explain that these feminist claims were not completely grounded, she does acknowledge that in film the industry is male dominated making the male gaze evident at some level, whether at editing or acting, as the system is “owned and operated by men” (Devereaux, 126). Interestingly, although one may argue that women can play the lead roles and direct films, the male-gaze does not simply mean that the viewer is male in anatomy. Women also are subject to being indoctrinated by films to believe in patriarchal assumptions that man is the subject and woman the object (Devereaux, 127). Due to the film industry’s powerful influence on the public, as confirmed by the study of Riefenstahl in the previous posts, gender is of importance in the images that the film presents. For example, the purpose of most movies today is entertainment, or to induce pleasure. However, “this pleasure characteristically takes the form of looking at women” (Devereaux, 132). On the other hand, men are rarely objectified in the presence of and for the pleasure of women. Although some may oppose Devereaux’s argument using evidence of feminist film makers and strong-willed heroines, the author quickly indicates the weakness of their argument. For example, in films such as Woman of the Year, when the strong female character breaks from the norm she is “revealed to be cold-hearted and in need of ‘reeducation’” (Devereaux, 128). In addition, the art of feminist filmmaking is primarily shown only in “film courses and private film societies,” (Devereaux, 139) not necessarily influencing mainstream audiences. Therefore, if any alternate point of view is even allowed to reach the public, the image of a strong woman is portrayed as negative.

Devereaux and Brand also address the issue of the universality of art. Brand indicates that although the theory is under fire, “art and aesthetic attention are both in some sense universal…[with] the same value for everyone” (Brand, 7). Devereaux makes clear that feminists challenge conventions of art interpretation and “propose that we reexamine art’s claim to speak for all of us” (Devereaux, 136). Devereaux explains that feminists base this argument on the idea that art does not speak in a gender-neutral voice and therefore cannot have universality. Rather, “seeing never escapes a way of seeing” (Devereaux, 127). What this phrase indicates is that when a person of any sex looks at a piece of art, he or she has a specific perspective, oftentimes dominated by the male gaze. Thus, due to conditioning from society, patriarchal perspectives are even adopted by female viewers. When a male gaze oriented viewer observes the work, it is with regards to the man as the subject and the woman as the object whose value is defined by her value to the man (Devereaux, 128). Feminists aim to change this pattern by encouraging “focus on the understanding [of] the development of gendered points of view and understanding the diverse positions of the masculine and feminine in culture” (Brand, 15). Interestingly, Brand indicates that “feminists have adapted psychoanalytic insights” (Brand, 15) in order to address such issues, a method to which Devereaux indirectly refers to. For example, when discussing individual perspectives, Devereaux mentions interpretations of the inkblot (Devereaux 122). The inkblot tests are one of the methods developed with Freud and his psychoanalytic theory to diagnose the subconscious. In the same way, society influences the public’s subconscious to the point that male-domination in images takes hold of the viewer’s perspective, often times unknowingly. For example, Devereaux mentions stereotypical images of women as “portraits of the Good Girl, the Vamp, and the Dutiful Wife” (Devereaux, 128) to which one realizes is indeed true, especially in film but also in paintings and scripts. The works below are of particular importance as they all attempt to challenge the male gaze, the first by fooling the viewer, the second by portraying a strong woman and the final by emphasizing the unity and equality of man and woman.





Joana Vasconcelos, chandelier made of tampons

Vasconcelo’s work is an enormous chandelier made of thousands of suspended tampons. The object is reminiscent of the Venetian glass chandeliers in its elegance and design. Upon first glance one would not realize the material which the art is made of. For example, to those who tend to shy away from abstract or feminist art, the viewer may see only the elegant chandelier. The fact that the creation is composed of tampons lends the message that beauty in art can be seen from any perspective and that perhaps a work or person may look like one thing but have the essence of another. The juxtaposition of material and final product creates irony within the art in which the feminist aspect surprises and may even shock.


Frida Kahlo

Kahlo’s work portrays a somewhat surreal image of a woman lying on a bed in a wasteland surrounded by anatomically representative objects attached to her with string. She is lying naked in the bed with a pool of blood. The image is very symmetrical with the objects and boards of the bed surrounding or perhaps encaging the woman. In the background one can see the image of an industrialized city which may be important in the message Kahlo is attempting to transmit. Notice also that the color scheme uses many shades of brown that seem to dirty the image and the strings and blood are red. The color red is often considered a power color in feminist works. The classic strong woman typical of Kahlo’s paintings also seems small in comparison to the bed and surrounding objects, in fact the baby appears to be as large if not larger than she is. Kahlo is emphasizing the prominence and importance of the feminine role in society. Even in an industrial world where the woman seems to be neglected, the woman’s reproductive roles and anatomy make her essential and strong. The woman’s confidence seems to be portrayed by the way in which she calmly is holding all of the strings representing her roles.


Louise Bourgeois, Seven in a Bed, 2001

Bourgeois’s work, known for its sexual emphasis and eroticism, portrays seven naked entities in human form wrapped around one another. Some of the bodies are connected together and counted as one. The bodies are so close together it is difficult to tell which are male and which are female. When two bodies are kissing they seem to be completely connected at the mouth while others are connected at the back of the head. As seen by the reflection in the glass, the legs line up in perfect harmony lending a unified sense to the work. The expressions on the faces of the bodies are passionate and intensely focused on one another. The joints also look like those of a doll. The way in which all of the bodies are interconnected may be focusing on the way in which bodies are passionate and unite to become one during intercourse. The fact that gender is indiscriminate may emphasize the equality among males and females.

Jessica D., Post 6

Jessica Duran


"Feminism is the radical notion that women are human beings"

-Cheris Kramerae.



Unfortunately, we live in a patriarchal society that not only dominates and oppresses women, but also propagates their inferiority and reinforces their dependency upon men (Devereaux 126). On a daily basis we are bombarded with degrading images of women on tv, film, music videos, and advertisements, and as a result have become desensitized to how women are still being dehumanized and exploited in our modern day society. In order to “survive” and prosper in our society women must conform to the “traditional” standard of female beauty and their primary roles as sexual objects for male scopophilic pleasure (Devereaux 132). Women have been conditioned by society to believe that they are solely objects to be appraised, judged, and validated by the male gaze (Devereaux 131). Unfortunately, women also view and judge other women from a male perspective; often sadistically sizing up their “competition” (Devereaux 120). Women are unrelentingly criticized for being vain and narcissistic, but sadly their very value and identities are determined by how well they can conform to the male ideal of an eroticized object of sexual desire. Her only “power” is to be seductively appealing and sexually attractive to men; therefore, driving many women to dress provocatively, wear lots of make up, diet, exercise excessively, and even resort to plastic surgery, in order to live up to these ideal feminine expectations that have been superimposed by men.

It is astonishing how one chromosome can have the power to not only determine an individual’s sex, but also can impart upon certain individuals the superiority and authority over those who lack this chromosome and are therefore genetically “inferior”. The inherent biological differences between males and females are apparent from the moment of conception and continue to increase exponentially well into adulthood. For example, it has been scientifically proven that the biological differences between male and female brains is the reason why men are more visual beings and women are better at expressing emotions and relating to other people. However, it is important to note that it is the combination of biological differences and societal and environmental influences that ultimately determines how each sex perceives the world around them and their role that they play in it. Gender in itself is a socially defined concept and our male-dominated society has conditioned us to “view” the world from a male perspective; thereby promoting discrimination against women and ultimately labeling them as inferior (Devereaux 127). Given these considerations it is reasonable to assume that gender discrimination, bias, and differences, will not only play a substantial role in the social, cultural, and political realms, but will also manifest itself into the art world too.






A misogynistic attitude in the art world is clearly apparent not only by the fact that women artists and their art have long been suppressed and labeled as inferior, but also in the manner in which women have been represented and portrayed in the arts by men. Male artists more often then not tailor their art to the tastes and erotic fantasies of the “assumed” heterosexual male viewer. In most pieces of artwork by men, women are not subjects, but objects that are to be judged, desired, controlled, showcased, and owned exclusively by men; therefore, defining the female body and identity as mere sexual objects created for the sole purpose of male “aesthetic contemplation” and pleasure (Devereaux 131). Gustave Courbet’s painting, Woman with a Parrot, is a model example of how the female body is normally sexually objectified and idealized in art that is created by male artists; therefore, satisfying the male fetishistic obsession with the female body and beauty. In this painting the female subject languidly reclines as she dazedly gazes up at the colorful parrot that has gracefully landed onto her delicate fingers. Her porcelain white skin is smooth and supple and her luxuriously thick hair gracefully cascades onto the white linen sheets that serve to strategically conceal her genital region. The sexual connotation to her posture accentuates her female curves and attentively displays her ample breasts. The viewer is allowed to steal a glimpse of her traditionally patriarchal aesthetically pleasing nude form without her knowledge or consent. She is sexually available and vulnerable and completely unaware of the intrusive voyeurism of the male gaze. She is an erotic object of male desire and fascination; in essence the flawless physical embodiment of the “ideal” female.






Gustave Courbet’s highly controversial painting, “The Origin of the World”, is another dynamic example of how male artists create art that exploits the female body in order to satisfy the voyeuristic male gaze. This painting crudely portrays a full-frontal depiction of a naked woman’s genitals. Her fleshy thighs are splayed wide opened; allowing the spectator to freely peruse her naked and exposed form. She is lying on a bed and appears to be sexually available and submissive. The view of her nether regions is carefully enshrouded by a thick patch of dark pubic hair and an erect nipple is barely concealed by a white linen sheet. It is quite obvious that this painting is heavily saturated with heterosexual male sexual fantasy; allowing them to vicariously play out their own erotic fantasies and desires, and in the process dehumanizing and degrading women to the status of a sexual object . The woman in this painting is but a headless, sexual object stripped of any identity, voice, or power; in essence the epitome of aesthetic pleasure for the male gaze.






Linda Nochlin’s famous question, “Why have there been no great women artists?”, sheds light on the discrimination and bias women artists and their artwork have faced and still continue to face in our patriarchal society. Gender constraints placed on women confined them to their biological roles as mother and caregiver; relegating them to the domestic sphere and its responsibilities. They were denied access to art school, teaching schools, and formal artistic training, and therefore often turned to needlepoint, knitting, crocheting, weaving, and embroidery, as means in which to freely express their artistic creativity and ingenuity (Brand 10). These artistic endeavors were denounced as being hobbies and the work they produced was labeled as mere crafts; not worthy of artistic merit or praise (Brand 11). Women were branded as incapable of producing “’fine” art; lacking the artistic “genius” innately inherent to male artists (Brand 10). Miriam Schapiro's series of etchings, Anonymous Was a Woman, is an artistic homage to the heritage of women artists and their art work. This artwork consists of a collection of etchings based on elaborately and ornately crocheted doilies created by nameless women. It celebrates and embraces the crafts of women that for so long have been depreciated and devalued by our society and elevates “women’s crafts” to the statues of “fine” art (Brand 11).



Sources Cited:

http://www.artchive.com/artchive/C/courbet/courbet_woman_with_parrot.jpg.html
http://courses.washington.edu/hypertxt/cgi-bin/12.228.185.206/html/contexts/origin.jpg
http://www.bluffton.edu/womenartists/womenartistspw/schapiro/schapiro3.html
Nochlin, Linda. "Why Have There Been No Great Women Artists?" (1971). In Women, Art, and Power, and Other Essays. Harper & Row, 1988.


Ruth D. Post 6

Ruth E. Day

What role does gender play in art? This is the question that Brand and Devereaux endeavor to answer. “Virtually all feminist interpretive strategies give rise to the philosophical question of whether and how the gender of artists – as well as their other socially marked identities - are to count as properties of works of art and to be recognized as aesthetically relevant,” (Brand, 16). They have two general theories that answer this question. The first is that most art takes on a male “gaze”. Most art is seen through the male point of view and when viewing art, women generally take on a male perspective. The perspective does not stop at art; it applies to the rest of the world as well. “Both men and women have learned to see the world through male eyes,” (122). Feminists see this as very sad because it as though women have buried their own perspectives and personalities so as to take on those of the dominant male. The male gaze saw women as either sexual objects or as mothers. Here are two examples of paintings that come from the beginning of the 1900s and the end of the 1800s women as seen from the male gaze:







The first painting, by Mary Cassat, is an example of a female painter taking on a male gaze. This painting shows a woman in her “natural place” as the male gaze would see it. A woman viewing this painting may take on the male gaze herself and believe that her purpose in life is to get married, have kids, and sit passively at home doing household tasks such as sewing while her husband goes to work and support her and the family. The second painting shows woman in a totally different light. It is titled “Madame X”, which suggests that the woman in the painting is a prostitute. Her face is turned away, because the viewer supposed to be paying attention to her body. Yes, it is a beautiful depiction of the female form but it implies that women should only be valued as the objects of men’s desires. Both of these images are degrading to women because they undermine women’s ability to be more than just mothers and sexual objects. These paintings also exemplify the two separate categories women were put into during this time in history. A woman was either a “good girl” or a “bad girl”. “The good girl was the dutiful daughter who preserved herself (that is, her virginity) for the right man ‘to take’ from her. The bad girl, in contrast, flaunts her sexuality indiscriminately, ‘losing’ her virginity or ‘giving it away’,”(Devereaux, 128). Such a division of women into one group or another is degrading and has developed by the vast majority of people being conditioned into seeing things through the male gaze. The solution to this way of thinking, according to Devereaux, is to create a female gaze. “This strategy is most often described as creating a female voice of female gaze. It allows women to write their own texts, their own history,” (Devereaux, 138).


The second theory put forth by Brand and Devereaux is that art created from the newly established female gaze tends to link art to the sexual politics whereas art from the male gaze tends to steer away from that area. “What is original to feminism is the linkage of art with sexual politics,” (Devereaux, 124). Art from the male perspective is more concerned with tradition and other areas of politics. Feminist art is out to make a statement about what it is to be a woman and contradict the misconceptions about the female role in the world as created by the male gaze. Below are some examples of art from this new female perspective.



These images were all created by feminist artists during the 1960s and 70s. A lot of the feminist art seems erotic and a little contradictory. Isn’t the whole point of feminist art to end the display of women as erotic objects? The answer to this question is yes. The first image is a photograph of the artist covered in chewing gum that she has molded into the form of female genitalia. The point of the photograph is that the artist no longer wants to be defined by her sexuality. She wants her existence to mean more than that. That is why the abbreviation “SOS” is an important part of the title of this piece. The second image, by Georgia O’Keefe, is a more abstract piece. O’Keefe was best known for her paintings of extreme close ups of beautiful flowers. Most of the time, these paintings resembled female genitalia. They weren’t meant to be sexual. Instead, they were meant to express the beauty of the female body as something very natural. Male genitalia had been shown in this light many times before (note the number of times phallic symbols have been used throughout history to represent power and fertility) but now that females were expressing the natural beauty of their anatomy it was considered overtly sexual and erotic by man viewers. For this reason, feminist art was frowned up and was not widely accepted as art until the early 90s. The last image, by Miriam Shapiro, is a collage of images associated with the traditional role of women. The female form in the center of the image is wearing an apron and seems ready for a change. She is held back by these traditional ideas of the female gender and is ready to create her own path.

Feminist art is meant to reestablish the role of women. It challenges tradition and calls for a change in how women are depicted in art. They stress that traditional art is not for everyone. It is created by men and women who see every thing through a male gaze. It is time for females to create their own gaze and see things through their own eyes. “They [feminists] replace reverence for art with skepticism. They ask that we be willing to rethink what we value and the reasons we value it,” (Devereaux 137). Feminists create an alternate way of looking at art that they call the female gaze and add an aspect of sexual politics to art.

Shea post 6

“Why have there been no great woman artists?” (Linda Nochlin) It is a good question. Unfortunately though, it is not all that difficult to answer. Women were denied access to positions of any artistic sophistication for so long that it was impossible for them to gain any recognition for their work. In regards to art, when men alone do the constructing, buying, selling, criticizing and praising, where do women fit in?

Odalisque by Joseph Sheppard

Right here. If "women are art" (Ryan Musgrave, possibly quoting someone else), how could they be expected to produce it? The perspective would be wrong all together, backward. This concept is addressed by Mary Devereaux as the "male gaze". She argues that approaching an image requires that you judge/measure it against your existing body of knowledge. The historical imbalance of power among gender dominates that body of knowledge. For example "'His' attributes define all humanity...our language, like our thinking equates 'male' gender with gender-neutral." (Devereaux, 122) "Representation of the world, like the world itself, is the work of men..." (Devereaux, 127). In other words, women are considered inadequate as artists because their work lacks the perspective that we recognize and have come to identify as valuable; the masculine perspective. "The value of art is linked with the special mind of artists, and thus these theories give rise to a picture of the artistic Genius, a figure deeply inflected with masculine properties both historically and conceptually." (Brand, 6)

Promenade, also be Joseph Sheppard, makes plain the assumption of a male viewer. In elevation, color and motion the men are apart from the women. It is clear that their only purpose is to be observed, by men of course. As spectators, we take on the same role as the man on the pedestal; "the spectator's gaze is male in two senses; both in its direction at women as objects of erotic fascination and its identification with the male protagonist." (Devereaux, 133) For this reason, even those who overcame the systematic exclusion of women from the artistic field could not achieve so called artistic genius. "Feminist scholarship has unearthed women artists, writers, and musicians of the past that were oftentimes well known, amply commissioned and self supporting in their day but were subsequently omitted from the canon of 'greats' in the written histories of art." (Brand, 10) The girl in back strikes me as a feminist. She maintains the connection with her gender with an outstretched arm but takes on some qualities of the men portrayed here. She is of a darker complexion than the other women and more static in her composure. Despite these efforts she is not able to achieve that position held by the man who reigns on high. She cannot become a man and is therefore without power, without greatness.

In light of the male gaze, creative projects undertaken by women, despite their utility, were not seen with any of the prestige of art. In order to recognize these works as artistic , the traditional standards of art's inherent components would have to be reevaluated. "As with earlier anti-essentialism, definitions of art were rejected. To feminists they were seen as oppressive: privileging 'high' art over low, 'fine' art over 'craft', men's art over women's." (Bland, 10) The daunting nature of this proposition was greeted with great resistance, as is the proposition of any widespread change.

Here we see a complete rejection of artistic standards in their relation to gender. Certainly the image is politically charged, but the politics of gender are the focus of this discussion. The woman is the object of the gaze, but she is an entirely different kind of object. Shirin Neshat's photograph is not at all erotic. Her body is covered from head to foot, eliminating the female position as an item of lust, a vamp. The violent implications of her gun and red hands also reject the woman as a manifestation of mothering nurture or helpless inaction. This woman is not innocent. "Reading against the grain is a strategy designed by out-of-power groups to counterbalance the dominant textual traditions by offering alternative interpretations of works within those traditions." (Devereaux, 139) The photograph presumes the perspective of no one in particular, and is therefore a renovation or a "re-vision" of artistic categorization's imperative patriarchy.

Tawny N post 6

Tawny Najjar

Art is often used to portray the customs and beliefs of the current society, and also to uphold those beliefs and ideals. However, the objects or ideals that are portrayed are not always accurate or representative of the entire population's beliefs. During the 1900s, American art was constantly redefined, whether it was by the Abstract Expressionist movement or by social movements, such as Feminism. In earlier years, before feminism began to gain prominence, the artwork was ruled by patriarchal themes and ideas. It was governed by patriarchy because art reflects what life is like, and society is very much male-dominated. Patriarchal ideals are based on the supremacy of the father and legal dependence of wives. The paintings were structured to appeal to the male population, portraying them to be “in action” – strong, powerful, and in control. However, the women were portrayed in a very different light. The artwork showed women as passive objects, placing importance on their appearance rather than their actions.

This sculpture, named Hades and Persephone, is a perfect example of male dominance over women. In the sculpture, Hades is grabbing Persephone, holding her hostage, against her will. This piece of art shows the vulnerability of women, and the idea that their purpose is to be pleasing to males. Persephone appears to be weakly fighting, as if she herself does not believe that she has the power or ability to protect and save herself. This implies that women cannot defend themselves in danger, and would therefore require male assistance. This degrading act highlights women's vulnerabilities.

This portrayal of women was even extended into display them as "eroticized" objects, which gave the male viewers a scopophilic pleasure. By "eroticizing" women, the male artists minimized their power and in turn, gave it to the male viewer. Women in artwork were now given a role, a position to fill for the men. They were expected to be beautiful, sensual, and most importantly, vulnerable. As Devereaux stated, “Women themselves must not be indifferent to the gaze turned upon them; they must have internalized a certain assignment of positions” (Devereaux 130). By portraying women as sensual and beautiful, the artists developed an ideal female, a vision which women were forced to aspire to. The patriarchal tone made women depend on men not only for their status and privilege, but for their identity. “Women, unlike men, do not learn to describe the world from their own point of view. As the ‘other,’ woman learns to submerge or renounce her subjectivity. She finds her identity in the subjectivity of men to whom she is attached (father, husband, lover). In the eyes of men, she finds her identity as the object of men’s desire” (Deveraux 127). Women were solely viewed in terms of their value to men, which caused their identity to be dependent on patriarchal confines. In one of his books, Plato talked about how artists can imitate what they see, yet they lack the knowledge of what it actually is. Congruently, male artists depicted women as what they viewed them to be, or wished them to be, yet these sensual paintings focused on the outer shell, rather than appreciating women for their intellect and character. In this patriarchal society, interpretation of artwork is influenced by the male gaze. "Men look both as spectators and as characters within works. In figurative terms, to say that the gaze is male refers to a way of seeing that takes women as its object. In the broad sense, the gaze is male whenever it directs itself at, and takes pleasure in, women, where women function as erotic objects” (Devereaux 121).

Sherman's Victorian Woman is an ideal example of one of the ways that women were portrayed. The painting depicts a woman reclining on a couch, head resting on her hand, and eyes staring off into the distance. She is dressed in a feminine gown, with her shawl gently falling off one shoulder, giving off the impression of sensual vulnerability and a strange sense of openness to the male spectator. She is well-dressed, and has an air of femininity about her. The subject seems to be contemplating about something, whether it is a preoccupation or a daydream, yet the focus is meant to be more on her appearance, rather than on the inner workings of her mind. In the patriarchal society, women were valued more for their skin-deep beauty, rather than their multifaceted temperament.


In this piece of artwork, You Are Not Yourself by Barbara Kruger, the artist captures the face of a woman's reflection in a shattered mirror. The piece illuminates deep and painful emotions. It captures the ultimate problem that women had with how they were depicted in paintings - their loss of identity. The paintings that portrayed women in a sensual, beautiful manner did not merely give women an image to strive for, but rather, an unattainable goal. In the patriarchal art society, women had to depend upon men for an identity. The shattered mirror represents the shattering of this woman's spirit and will; she is not able to attain that role of perfection and beauty. She does not know who she is, nor does she know who she wants to be.

The art world was male-dominated for many reasons, each having to do with a struggle of power. Art institutions were largely populated by men; if there were many female artists that could create what they wanted, the men still had the ability and the power to influence their preference of art. This manipulation of art positioned women in ways that remained consistent with patriarchal assumptions, restraining them from creating works that were too controversial or gender-related. The male control lead to pieces whose “content and style inscribe the patriarchal unconscious of the culture at large” (Devereaux 133). This positioned the audience to find a different manner of seeing the artwork in a way that calms their fears and satisfies their desires. To keep the status quo, the paintings retained themes that were “normal” and widely accepted. Another idea that kept power from female artists was that “women ARE art,” thus implying they were meant to be viewed as objects judged by male viewers, rather than being the viewer or the judge (Feminist aesthetic power point 8/1/07). This male-dominated art society also kept women from training, exhibiting, selling, and having their artwork collected. There was slow access to art schools and training, little access to top positions in the artistic field, and the traditional canon of works was overwhelmingly male (Feminist aesthetics power point 8/3/07).

After enduring this patriarchally themed society, women came together to criticize and change its views. The feminist goals in art were to gain equality between men and women artists, as well as to include some of the famous female artists in the “canon”. Feminists discredited the popular theory that art and aesthetic attention are universal tenets. “By ‘universal,’ it is asserted that art and aesthetic value possess at least ideally the same value for everyone, that they bind people together in experience” (Brand 7). They have criticized that the universal subject is “historically situated (masculine, patriarchal, and imperialistic)” (Brand 8). This feminist movement offered a means of resistance, and an alternative to the male gaze (Devereaux 139). Initially, female artists did not have much success gaining influence and recognition for their works. However, in 1971, Linda Nochlin wrote an essay titled “Why Have There Been No Great Female Artists?” which launched a movement that focused on women’s involvement in the arts. Linda questioned whether the traditional forms of fine art were overlooking the creative and unique pieces of art that female artists had created. When female artists first started creating art for the public to view, they de-gendered it, and left out any feminist connotations, preferring to have their artwork be accepted rather than make a statement. However, as time went on, female artists began to branch out. A “new art history” began to take hold, emphasizing the “work of art itself as a piece of history” as opposed to the traditional focus on “the development and achievement of period styles, the history, or the sequence of works” (Brand 10).

When female artists first began developing their artwork, the patriarchal society sought to marginalize it and devalue it. It was devalued because people did not want a change of ideas and customs. Thus, there was a natural resistance to the overthrow of a common way of thinking. To take feminism seriously would mean to rethink the basic, entrenched concepts of how a society should be. As a result, many great female artists who were well-known, amply commissioned, and self-supporting were omitted from the “canon of the greats” in the histories of art (Brand 10). However, on an interesting point, there is an argument that “there is no feminist art but only art that can be read as feminist” (Grove Art Online). This being said, just because an artist was female did not necessarily mean that she was trying to use her artwork as a means to bring about a change in the power balance between male and female artists.

As was obviously seen when female artists attempted to gain recognition for their artwork, gender does affect the norms and discipline of art. There was a great division between high art and low art, fine art and craft. High art is characterized by its authenticity and uniqueness, its aesthetic style, and sometimes by whether it is displayed for public viewing. Despite these qualifications for determining high art, female artists were not given equal treatment regarding their artwork. Though many females became accomplish artists, the “canon of the greats” remained entirely male. Artwork done by females was viewed as mediocre and almost as good as male works of art, but the thought that a woman could exceed a male’s work was ludicrous. In film clip # 3, Marsha Tucker talked about how it was a high compliment when some one told her that her work was as good as a man’s. High art was always the male’s domain, while women’s art was, in a sense, substandard. However, as Devereaux stated, “Does ‘great’ art mean the forcefully written on the spare, the heartfelt, or the coolly reasoned, the typical or the innovative. When is a text forcefully written, and who decides?” (Devereaux 136). Rather than judging the aesthetic value of the different paintings and artwork, people were more likely to judge based on sex, and what that sex implied – whether the painting carried additional, implied messages based on whether it was a male or female. Gender norms also affected the types of art that women created. Female artists created artwork that depicted what was familiar to them, whether it was from their lives as housewives, single and independent women, or lovers. Many paintings dealt with fashion, nature, and beauty. Female artists also portrayed females very differently in their art than male artists did. There was a split between female artists – one side felt that women should be proud and comfortable with their sexuality, that it empowered them and made them one with nature. These female artists created paintings that depicted nude women, yet their paintings did not carry the same sexual connotation that male paintings did. The nudity was not meant for the enjoyment of men, but rather for the enjoyment of women, an invitation for them to accept who and what they were. Hannah Wilke, a female artist in the 1970s, documented herself. She took several shots of herself in the nude, covering her body with pieces of gum to represent imperfections and scarring. She used herself as the subject to show that, even though she worked behind the scenes by creating these works of art, she still existed and had a voice. However, her work was deemed too controversial and provocative (film clip # 1). On the other side of the rift was the group of women that believed that women should be modest and pure. Their paintings were more unpretentious, though they still possessed the same level of skill and aptitude. Gender norms affected how artists created their works, for in the male-dominant society, the assumed viewer was male. All of the works of art were aimed at a male audience, and thus catered to the needs and desires of male viewers.

Georgia O'Keefe was known for her floral paintings, which depicted the sensuality of the female body. In her painting, Red Canna, O'Keefe uses the brush strokes and vibrant colors to display life and vividness. Most of her paintings were images of the female sexual organs, which were carefully constructed to look like flowers, or vice versa. O'Keefe is one of the many examples of female artists who celebrated the sensuality and sexuality of women.

During the 1900s, the previous notion of art and artists was drastically changed. There was a sense of “out with the old and in with the new.” Though these news ideals and concepts did not come without a struggle, they opened the minds of viewers, and opened doors for many people who were previously unable to express their artistic abilities. During this time, female artists began to make their mark in art history, though they fought a battle to achieve this. However, when one considers this battle, one must think ahead to the results. What would happen if female artists were given the exact same privileges and recognition as men? If there was equality, then the assumed viewer could no longer be male, which would lead to the idea that the gender of the viewer would not matter. Rather, the importance would be placed on the viewer’s own experiences and views. In addition, would the portrayal of women change, and for what gender of artist? Females would be given more power, because they could no longer be degraded as sexual objects. However, would they still be sexual, or would they be stripped of their sensuality, as was attempted in Nazi Germany? Lastly, since the equality between male and female artists took away that male-domination, would there then be a “universal view?” Art has come a long way in the past few centuries, always changing and forcing people to consider new ideas and concepts. One can only imagine what future artists will do to revolutionize the way people see and think.

kelly post 6

Both articles overwhelmingly support the theory that gender is related to the formal components and artistic choices that artists make. They each also went beyond this theory to suggest that gender also affects the way art is viewed and accredited by the audience. Brand and Korsmeyer suggest that the view of a stereotypical successful artist has already been ingrained into the minds of the audience when they say “…the value of art is linked with the special mind of artists, and thus these theories give rise to a picture of the artistic Genius, a figure deeply inflected with masculine properties both historically and conceptually” (p.6). This comment implies that our culture is less comfortable with an artist who doesn’t fit historical norms. The “artistic Genius” that Brand refers to is based off tradition – in other words, if the artist isn’t traditionally male, the audience might subconsciously be less inclined to appreciate the art that they automatically link to the responsible artist.

Brand and Korsmeyer adopt an additional perspective when they suggest that, “…the state of aesthetic contemplation is a principal instance of intrinsic value; it takes one out of one’s own self-concerns and peculiarities and into a state of mind that may be shared by any other human being” (p. 7). If this argument is true, then it might be difficult for females and males to easily flow into that “shared state of mind” because both genders encompass such different biological and chemical make-ups. An example where that problem might arise is when a male examines Gray Line with Black, Blue and Yellow by Georgia O’Keeffe. Two bodies, standing tailbone to tailbone surround a dark area. Those bodies are pale, smooth, and delicate. The painting’s dark, central area resembles that of a vagina and also a bloomed flower. The link between flowers and vaginas suggest the delicate beauty that vaginas evoke. If a flower has not yet bloomed, its beauty cannot be recognized, and the same is also true for a woman. A woman cannot be considered beautiful until she has experienced puberty and embraced the changes and beauty of her body. The image becomes increasingly dark as you look towards the center suggesting the mystery of a woman’s insides. Man and woman would view this piece in a different light simply because women experience less mystery when it comes to the female vulva, naturally. This is where taking one “out of one’s own self-concerns and peculiarities and into a state of mind…shared by any other human being” might become complicated due to gender roles. Another picture depicting the mystery of the female vulva is Three Apples. Just as O'Keeffe's painting establishes the dark area as the mysterious area of the female vagina, it also relates the vagina to nature using the apples.

http://www.michelangelo.com/okeeffe/images/grayline.jpg

Georgia O'Keeffe, Gray Line with Black, Blue and Yellow, c. 1923

http://www.feministezine.com/feminist/modern/images/FeministArt-Taiwan-03.gif

Yan Ming-Huy, Three Apples

Mary Devereaux takes the same approach to how gender relates to the formal and artistic components that artists choose. She uses a very simplified explanation to show how gender plays a role with the audience and the artist: the male gaze. “ [It] refers to a way of seeing that takes women as its object. In this broad sense, the gaze is male whenever it directs itself at, and takes pleasure in, women, where women function as erotic objects” (p.1). In this next piece, a woman stands posed with a backless wrap that is slipping down her body. Her hair is pulled up with both hands. In this picture, the woman exists to the “male gaze” as an erotic object. She suggests beauty at its highest. This painting might oppress women because it idealizes one type of beautiful that was famous during the Renaissance period. It contributes to those movements where women are expected to be one type of gorgeous, and not gorgeous in their own right. The woman’s face is not even depicted, but instead only the part that might appeal to a male figure is shared. The female goes to the extent of perhaps being even enticing to the male viewer; she is painted to suggest a certain sexual tension or inspiration.

http://www.picturethisgallery.com/Artists/Pino/Dressing%20Table.jpg

Pino, Dressing Table

Fatema, Post 6

Fatema Kermalli

The first formal aspect that, in many works of art, may be related to the concept of gender is the positioning of subjects within the painting. A difference can be noted between the placement of males and females. “The male-controlled institutions of filmmaking thus place women on screen in a particular position” (Deveraux 129-30). Also worth examining here is the “body language” of the subjects: the way they hold themselves and, more specifically, the way each holds his or her head.

Females in art are usually seen in a position of submission to a dominant male figure. Devereaux states: “As the ‘other’, woman learns to submerge or renounce her subjectivity. She finds her identity in the subjectivity of the men to whom she is attached… In the eyes of men, she finds her identity as the object of men’s desire” (127). This idea is clearly depicted within the painting by Henri Pierre Danloux of a poet and his wife. Here the wife is placed below her husband. She is sitting on the floor and literally looking up to her husband, as if expectantly waiting for him to bestow some more “poetic” wisdom on her. He, on the other hand, stands up straight and tall above her. He appears lost in his own thoughts and is looking away from his wife into the distance-acting as though she didn’t exist.

Another example lies in the comparison of two pieces; one depicting a female (milkmaid) and a horse, the other with a male (captain) and horse as the subjects. The female is shown leaning on the horse for support, as though she is incapable of standing up by herself. This is similar to what Devereaux mentions regarding film: “At the simplest level, Haskell and others had maintained, film reinforced women’s dependence on men” (128). Her facial expression also appears to be one of fatigue; even though her gaze does meet that of the viewer, her look is more one of disinterest than it is a look filled with defiance, courage, or high self-esteem. Contrastingly, the male, though he does not face the viewer, gives off an air of confidence. It is as though he does not deign to look at the viewer (rather than looking away from them in fear or shame). He does not lean on anything, but stands upright whilst actually holding the horse (who is obviously frightened of something) in place. While the female’s form with its curves, and the way she is seen leaning into the horse, seems to refer to a liquidity of movement (symbolizing her willingness to “give in” and be easily persuaded), that of the male is straight and unyielding (perhaps referring to a supposed firmness of mind that former societies would have not thought present within the female).

Hence the development of feminist “…critiques of the broad Western tradition…that the universal subject is historically situated (masculine, patriarchal, imperialistic)…” (Brand 7-8).

The second formal aspect under discussion is the actions that females are depicted engaging in, and how this may relate to the fact that they are, indeed, females. This aspect of the art is also connected in part to the question of who the intended audience is.

In the introduction by Brand and Korsmeyer, it talks about the definitions “privileging ‘high’ art over low, ‘fine’ art over craft, men’s art over women’s” that feminists found oppressive (11). If we go back to the picture of the poet and his wife, we can see that here again, there is a disparity in the type of actions that each person is engaged in. The man is apparently generating poetry; he is doing creative work of the mind creating a type of “art” that may be said to afford “an escape from the individual ego and unites all who experience it in a common appreciation, transhistorical and transcultural” (Brand 7). His wife, on the other hand, is writing down what he says. The work of a simple scribe, this act of transcribing ideas is both figuratively and literally placed below that of actually creating the ideas themselves.

The same idea can be applied to the horse paintings. The female in the picture, as per the title, is a milkmaid… a great contrast to the captain, with his assumed many great deeds and intrinsically action-packed lifestyle.

Beyond this, the actions of women in art may actually be said to be a performance for male viewers. As Brand states: “Supplanting older notions of aesthetic perception, theories of the gaze analyze the pleasure to be found in representation by bringing to light the consciousness of the culturally prescribed viewer: a male of dominant social standing” (15-6). Such performance for the male eye is present within the painting of The Pleiades… depicting females scantily covered by “drapes” that appear to be in the middle of a type of ethereal dance. Their movements are painted in such a way that “shows a lot of skin” and may be arousing to the typical male viewer for whom it appears to have been created. They are present within the scene of the painting as they are for the very reason of attracting or pleasing male viewers. Hence the necessity for a sign such as the one created by the Guerrilla Girls regarding the number of pictures of nude women within the Met Museum. (The typical female would not appear to be much more intrigued by the half-clothed women as compared to fully clothed dancers.) Here we see women displaying themselves and being offered for public view, or “consumption”, a tradition that Devereaux maintain is longstanding: “Nevertheless, within the Hollywood film there is a long tradition of women performing for the camera. Women sing, dance, dress, and undress, all before the steady, often adoring, gaze of an implied spectator” (129). Also noticeable here is a “cultural proclivity to treat the female body and the female self only as objects of aesthetic contemplation” (131).

Images:

http://www.artres.com/c/htm/CSearchZ.aspx?o=&Total=28&FP=3820764&E=22SIJMYID8C@4&SID=JMGEJND8DAWND&Pic=14&SubE=2UNTWANSFJ3S

http://www.artres.com/c/htm/CSearchZ.aspx?o=&Total=1500&FP=3816116&E=22SIJMYID8J@I&SID=JMGEJND8DGOY5&Pic=680&SubE=2UNTWAK0YCMJ

http://www.artres.com/c/htm/CSearchZ.aspx?o=&Total=19&FP=3865649&E=22SIJMYIDWKUP&SID=JMGEJND8DM20Q&Pic=19&SubE=2UNTWAX3L27M

http://www.artres.com/c/htm/CSearchZ.aspx?o=&Total=3&FP=3865841&E=22SIJMYIDOBI5&SID=JMGEJND8DMDMD&Pic=1&SubE=2UNTWAOYH1WH