Wednesday, October 3, 2007

Aaron Post 6

Aaron Childree











The struggle for women to gain an equal footing in all aspects of society is one that has been going on for much of history. While some of these issues (women’s suffrage for example) were resolved long ago, some areas of society have taken a much longer time to allow women in to their historically male-dominated culture. Art is one of these fields of study. This is because, unlike voting rights, you cannot just pass a law that gives women an equal opportunity to create and make known their art. While the playing field, in respect to gender, is slowly being leveled in the visual arts, doing so requires the rejection of thousands of years of patriarchal tradition. Mary Devereaux argues that in order to give women the respect they deserve in the visual arts, we cannot just add their names to a list of well known artists, we must undergo what she refers to as a “conceptual revolution” (p.125).

One of the major influences gender has on art is that it traditionally looks through the male lens. This idea of the “male gaze” is one of the most important concepts to understand when talking about the role gender plays in art. Feminists would argue that not only is art literally from the male point of view because men are making it, but also that when women do make art it still assumes a male gaze because of the patriarchal ideas that have been engrained in their heads from birth. Because of this, women are seen as objects in most art. Men can be identified by intellect or athleticism or any number of things, but women can only be evaluated according to their beauty and, essentially, their worth to men. Mary Devereaux references Laura Mulvey on this subject, saying that “man is the bearer of the gaze, women its object” (Devereaux, p.121). A perfect example of the objectification of women in art is shown in the first image above, entitled Birth of Venus. This work of art was painted by Sandro Botticelli in the year 1444. The sensuality in this painting is very obvious and shows that women have been seem as objects in art for hundreds of years. Another example that is more recent is Amedeo Modigliani’s painting Reclining Nude (image #2) which was painted in 1917. The woman is lying down fully exposed (as the title suggests) and has a very seductive look on her face. This painting supports Devereaux’s idea that the male is assumed to be the spectator of art. The women is again shown as an object of beauty for the male eye.

Another major influence is the long and sometimes seemingly unbreakable patriarchal tradition that has run and still runs (although maybe to a lesser extent) the world in which we live. If you just take a quick survey of well-known artists throughout history, you will find a remarkably small number of women mentioned anywhere. This has raised the question of why women are not making large contributions to the visual arts. Is it that women haven’t been given the education and resources to create “great” art, or is that they have created “great” art, but were not able to promote it as well because of their lack of standing in society? Most people today would argue that there were plenty of women creating art on par with the men of their time, but their art was still considered inferior because as women they were “out of their element” as artists. Women were supposed to do practical things like cooking, house-keeping, and raising the children. Devereaux gives lots of examples of how the idea of the stereotypical house-wife is promoted through Hollywood and the film industry. On p.128 Devereaux gives examples of different ways girls are portrayed in the movies and then shows how all these portrayals are there to promote the notion of the “good girl” as a “dutiful daughter who preserved herself” and the bad girl as someone who “flaunts her sexuality indiscriminately”. This shows that women are still being identified by there involvement (or lack thereof) with men. An example of art that portrays this struggle is The Broken Column by Frida Kahlo (the third image above). Kahlo was in a horrible car accident at age 18, and lots of her art focuses on the pain she went through recovering from that accident. This painting shows her tied up in bandages and presumably wanting out. This could be seen as the artist’s way of saying that women artists are being held back and that they want to escape and be free to express their ideas on the canvas. The bandages holding her back and causing her pain are the patriarchal tradition.

Gender has played a large role in the history of art and the overall study of aesthetics. I think making it easier for women artists to express themselves is an important step that needs to be taken, but it is also important to remember that feminism isn’t gender neutral either. While most feminists only claim to want equality between men and women and nothing further, the idea of feminism comes with an inherent bias towards women. We should see feminism as a movement created to bring the “gender spectrum” back to neutral, not as an extreme movement trying to turn the tables and create a female-dominated society. On p.139, Devereaux states the feminist movement’s role as “a means of resistance” and also talks about the bias associated with feminism when she claims, “so too a feminist perspective is not, nor should it be regarded as, politically neutral”. It is the idea of tradition and resistance that keeps us from going too far in either direction on the political spectrum, and feminism is an important part of that equation.

Ashley G., Post 6

Ashley Green



Hannah Wilke, an influential feminist artist stated that, “People would rather look at women than look art.” Yet, much of art in history has focused on the female form as a paradigm for beauty. Though limiting in its view of the female form, one must inquire into whether or not it is the art that is sexist, or art as a whole. It is here that the concept of the “male gaze” becomes truly important to the discussion of women in art. According to Deveraux, the notion of the “male gaze” is at the heart of recent feminist theories on how art is viewed. The “male gaze” can be interpreted in two ways; in a literal sense it refers to the actual act of looking, and “the gaze is male when the men do the looking.” In a metaphorical sense, it refers to a way of thinking about, and acting in, the world. (Devereaux 121) Feminist theorists also often relate the idea of the male gaze to the concept of patriarchy. Thus, through the male gaze imposes the male perception of art on the female. With the male gaze, women are purely viewed as objects, often erotic objects. This depiction is seen throughout most of art history.



In my opinion, no other painting embodies the ideas of both the male gaze and traditional Western Aesthetics as Ivo Saliger’s interpretation of the Judgement of Paris. First off, the male, Paris, is literally gazing at the female in the work. The other females look like the have already faced their judgement and are therefore resituating themselves. One woman wears a look of indifference- she knows she has been judged as unworthy, and is resolved to the fact that she was being judged in the first place. Her role was to being judged, and she fulfilled it. The female Paris deems worthy, meaning the most beautiful and correct vision of what a female should be, is rewarded with an apple, which in my mind represented knowledge. The interpretation of the apple as knowledge also adds another layer to the male gaze; knowledge can only be transposed by and through men. They decide what beauty for the female is and what is fit to be known by the female.

Feminist theories, on the whole, are meant to serve as an alternative to the male gaze. At the heart of feminist theory lies the concept that women are equal beings in relation to men. Feminists are thus highly critical of the hierarchy of power that exists in the male dominated world, and fight to alter the assumption that men are superior to women. Feminists in art work to alter the dominance of men in art through creating works that both exemplify their struggle, their ideas, and reclaim the idea of beauty for themselves. As previously stated, one way in which women attempt to reclaim the perception of their own bodies is by creating artwork that depicts the female for in an untraditional ways. One of the artists that I believe does this in a most effective manner is Georgia O’Keefe.



Georgia O'Keefe's work is known to often contain a vaginal motif. What is interesting, however, is the use of color and design in her work. The usage of color would normally indicate that the work was floral, and the above painting does look like a flower. O'Keefe creates an image of the female form that is both erotic and sensual, without degrading or demeaning the female form as a whole. Yet, if a female depicts a feminine form in an erotic setting, how does that alter the concept of the male gaze? Does is it still uphold the paradigm, or does it create a new one. This was a question that feminist artists had to grapple with in creating their art. By creating work that was provocative or erotic, they could be furthering the function of the male gaze, or by creating such works, they could be reclaiming the female form for themselves. We classify how men view women in art as the “male gaze,” but does that mean that there is conversely a “female gaze” or a way in which women view women in art? Devereaux noted that feminist hold a basic tenet that “no vision, not even an artistic vision, is a neutral vision,” so how women’s vision is expressed seems to be of the utmost importance.



Another feminist artist that pushed to change how women are viewed is Hannah Wilke. Wilke's artwork is highly provocative and often times erotic. In her earlier work, Wilke's addressed the issue of intellect and beauty within the female form. She spoke on the idea that if women were beautiful, they couldn’t be smart. Either you had to be a sex object or a hyper-intellectual being. There was no balance in the view of women. Hannah Wilke’s work was an intentional challenge to the paradigm of intellect, intelligence, and femininity. Her later work further contemplates the ideal of beauty in art. The male gaze generally only shows women in art as young, nubile, and reflects a certain body image that is favored at the time. Wilke's work shows that the male gaze is not only an issue of beauty in the female form, but how we perceive that beauty at various ages. Wilke's work shows how beauty in the female form transcends age and circumstance.


Gender is completely relevant to the traditional internal norms of the discipline of art. The fact that we even place a distinction on female artist shows how today the traditional internal norms are still upheld. In traditional Western art, it is considered that most relevant art comes from men. Even when discussing modern movements, outside of the feminist movement, we focus on male artist over the female artist. When we discuss Abstract Expressionism, we first think of Jackson Pollock and not Joan Mitchell. When considering Pop Art, we think of Andy Warhol and Richard Hamilton, but never acknowledge a female counterpart. Though research shows that there have been female artists in the past, only the work of men have been deemed worthy enough to chronicle and study. Women in art were viewed from a purely aesthetic standpoint- they were pretty to look at. The concept of “feminist art” itself can be viewed as devaluing and degrading. Though the intent of feminist art is to reclaim and restructure how women in art or viewed, the fact that there must be a distinction in what is female art and what is male art upholds the traditional normative values of male-dominated art- women are not equal. The feminist art movement itself almost seems to take on a ‘separate but equal’ quality, yet achieves only the separate. Furthermore, any art deemed relevant produced by a female artist is the relegated to it's own separate exhibition or museum, one that holds only female art, where her art is still likely only being viewed by woman, and therefore still misses the mark of equality. Gender is still clearly relevant to the internal norms of art.


Brand and Korsmeyer themselves state that it is inarguable that art is a timeless source of everlasting value. (Brand, Korsmeyer 6) Because art is often viewed as a signifier of our cultural and historical past, one must wonder what the art of the present will tell future generations about how people were valued. Women’s value in past art is highly evident; traditionally they were viewed as both objects of beauty and objects of sex. Art historian Linda Nochlin suggests that because off its history, the traditional idea of fine art (and attendant concepts such as genius) may continue to overlook the creative products customarily undertaken by women. (Brand, Koysmeyer 11) We now hold a critical opportunity to reshape the perception of women in art, but influence how women are viewed in general for future generations. The role of feminism in art is a paramount one for now. A radical and comprehensive shift towards woman artist is necessary for any semblance of balance to be established.







Joe K. Post 6

Joe Kelly

Putting together an accurate and complete history of women in art is a difficult task for scholars of art. This is not merely because there were fewer women artists in previous eras, due to restrictive gender roles; that was certainly a factor, but there are others to be considered. For instance, women did partake in many forms of art which are both marginalized and unsigned, leaving no evidence of who exactly created the art. This art was expressed through activities that were usually a part of household activities, such as weaving and embroidering.

However, formal art, the kind that men could acquire fame from, was not practiced widely by women for a very long time. In fact, it was not until roughly the Renaissance era when women began to achieve international recognition. Even then, these women were usually forgotten or marginalized in art history, never considered as "great" artists until much, much later.

Even now, issues of gender effect debates over artistic studies. As Devereaux mentions, women in art are often portrayed positively or negatively depending on their utility toward men. For instance, virginal, dutiful daughters are often portrayed in a positive light, because that is a disposition that is generally demanded by a patriarchal society. This mindset very clearly has consequences for the creation of art. Devereaux speaks in great detail about the "male gaze," which, if utilized by an artist, contributes to this portrayal of women in only ways in which men want to see them.

The following two images both employ use of the male gaze. The left painting, An Interlude by William Sergeant Kendall portrays a mother and a child. Motherhood, being an acceptable role for women, is often portrayed as the only acceptable role for an adult woman, because it is a benefit to men. The painting on the right is Minerva Dressing by Lavinia Fontana, and also utilizes the male gaze by portraying a woman in a sexually enticing way. It is interesting that this painting would employ the "male gaze" despite being painted by a female, but the gaze is independent of the gender of the actual artist. Instead, male gaze is dependent on the attitude with which the art is created.





















The following piece, Lady Liberty by Laurent Dareau, is an example of feminist art:


This work counteracts male gaze, because it portrays completely different (in fact, completely opposite) attributes of female behavior as positive. This woman, in a piece of art that used male gaze, would either be looked at as a negative influence, or as something to be desired and then subjugated by men. In this work, it is her freedom that makes her a positive female figure.

Christopher Post 6

Christopher McCauley

To jump right into the question at hand, I personally feel that gender should matter when it comes to art, and for that matter, with anything. However, it seems that the majority of the human population disagrees, so I will continue to analyze the role of gender in art.

I would first like to look at the “art” created by Hannah Wilke. I definitely think that Wilke’s gender had everything to do with her creations—I do not think that a man would create such an atrocity and call it art. Mary Devereaux said “man is the bearer of the gaze, woman its object.” I believe Wilke had a similar idea in her head, and wanted to create something completely feminine, and completely outrageous—something nobody (more specifically, no man) has ever done before. She wanted her art to have a feminine gaze. I think perhaps that this is a good idea; however I also think she missed the mark quite a bit, and just created fetish pornography. I absolutely do not see how her art is supposed to help, or portray women in a positive way. She has portrayed herself as vulnerable and ugly. She has portrayed herself as an object of disgust. I was deeply disturbed when I first saw her photography, and it made me think she should have received some psychiatric treatment. “The male gaze is not always male, but is always male-dominated” (Devereaux, 126). A viewer can not help to look at these images without a male gaze, and be filled with repugnance.

This next piece of art, Blind, by Ryoko Suzuki, takes a very literal interpretation of the “male gaze” of art. This photograph features a woman who is “blinded” by bloody cords. This is kind of an ironic piece because it was created by a woman, most likely intended to mock this view. “…those who are oppressed look in spite of the restriction not to do so.” (Devereaux, 120; a quotation taken from the previous page on the reading). This image shows the degradation (Devereaux, 130) that women have faced in the area of art. This disturbing image tries to show how disgusting and wrong this has been. Compared with Wilke, Suzuki portrays this message much better, because she does not show the female body as a disgusting object, but as something that has been blocked, or held back by something disgusting.

Jack-In-The-Pulpit No. IV, by Georgia O’Keefe is a painting of a beautiful flower. However, when you look more closely, you can see that it resembles the female genitalia. “Feminist theorists urge us to reconsider our relationship to established artistic traditions.” (Devereaux, 136). By portraying the female anatomy through different means, and in a beautiful way, she is showing that the female body is beautiful. This advanced femininity in art, and I all aspects of culture by giving it a positive, forward stance in the art world. There is nothing “degenerate,” “ugly,” or “degrading,” about this art.

Jenn Post 6

Jenn Shea


In the introduction to “Aesthetics and Its Traditions,” Brand and Korsmeyer identify a thesis supported by many theorists that “whatever value art has, it possesses autonomously. The aesthetic qualities of art are thus available for appreciation without reliance on knowledge of anything outside the work of art itself” (16). Despite the fact that this intrinsic appreciation of art would be ideal, common experience of both the human viewing and creation of art suggest otherwise; creating and perceiving art are subject to judgment based on factors such as historical context, race, personal values, and most importantly here, gender.

An important point to consider is that although aesthetics attempts to solely encompass the beauty of an object and not the context, in most cases, a perceiver or an artist determines the beauty of a piece of art by the historical, cultural, religious, or gender context. One idea of feminist aesthetics is to move away from the idea of aesthetics being autonomous from context. Gender affects both the perceiver and the creator of the artwork in such a way that women are typecast into having particular roles or forms in works of art and are thus seen in certain and usually erotic or sensual ways by the viewer. As the artist, the woman, who should have a more feminine gaze, is still subject to the common male gaze or is disregarded as an artist with claims that her work is “low” art.

One main theme that Devereaux and Brand and Korsmeyer discuss is the prevalence of the male gaze in art, whether the gaze is cast by the artist or by the viewer. Devereaux identifies the resulting objectification of women when portrayed through the male gaze: “…to say the gaze is male refers to a way of seeing that takes women as its object. In this broad sense, the gaze is male whenever it directs itself at, and takes pleasure in, women, where women function as erotic objects” (Devereaux121). Devereaux also goes more in-depth on this point, specifically addressing the male gaze in film as the film-maker, actors, and viewers of Hollywood are all involved in this male objectification and sensual portrayal of women in order to please the male viewer. In addition, she states, “…the spectator’s gaze is male in two senses, both in its direction at women as objects of erotic fascination and in its identification with the male protagonist” (133). She also argues that regardless of whether or not the viewer or creator is male, the gaze is always male-dominated. From this point of view, women are objectified in art and are depicted most often as erotic and sensual as to please the heterosexual male eye. Devereaux argues further that women also view art through a male gaze because they “judge themselves according to internalized standards of what is pleasing to men” (122). Another main change involved in the feminist movement can be seen in the Guerilla Girls posters that can be seen in the class power point that satirically point out that in order for art to be enjoyable and to be recognized as good art, it must in some way objectify women and show them without clothing on.

In this painting “Jupiter and Antiope, 1851” by Jean Auguste Dominique Ingres, Jupiter (or Zeus is Greek mythology) is seen watching Antiope, a naked woman laying on the ground. The painter not only portrays a sense of a dominant male that the viewer would relate to in the context of the painting in referencing the forceful capture of Antiope by Jupiter; he also portrays Antiope in a very sensual way with the way he positions her body. Her body encompasses the ideal curvy female physique in an arguably sexually inviting position. It is also interesting to note that in this painting, Zeus’ genitals remained concealed by a bush, while Antiope’s breast are plainly visible. This also shows how this piece of art was directed to please the heterosexual male viewer.

In contrast, this painting of Frida Kahlo’s, “The Broken Columb” portrays a nude woman, but rather than portraying her sensually in order to please the male eye, Kahlo makes the woman’s face seem very masculine in its features and makes what would be an ideal feminine physique grotesque by splitting it in two and by sowing nails sticking out of it. This, although in context actually representative of the injury Kahlo received in a bus accident, reminded me of the Hannah Wilke art from the movie clip about the feminist artist in that at first, the male gaze would be drawn to the presentation of the woman’s body but would then lose interest when realizing that the woman is not being eroticized. To some, the Wilke art in which she places gum all over her body or takes photos of herself as an aged woman may seem almost degenerate and inappropriate, but they actually put an interesting spin on the portrayal of women’s bodies and how individuals in today’s society only want view them in their most perfect and ideal form. I found some of the reactions among my classmates about that video clip quite interesting as just because she had gum on her body, her nudity was seen as more insulting and less artistic.

Another way in which gender affects art is within the idea that male art was once and perhaps still is considered to be superior to the work of female artists. Male artists were looked at as genius and creators of fine art. In reference to the quotes from philosophists Hume and Heidegger involving timeless great art, Brand and Korsmeyer state, “However, the collateral ideas that are invoked to explain the timeless value of art are ones that have come in for sharp critique from feminists. The brief quotes above indicate, for example, that the value of art is linked with the special mind of artists, and thus these theories give rise to a picture of the artistic Genius, a figure deeply inflected with masculine properties both historically and conceptually” (Brand, Korsmeyer 6-7). One of the objectives of feminist theory is to eliminate rigid ways of looking and defining art. From Brand and Korsmeyer, “As with earlier anti-essentialism, definitions of ‘art’ were rejected. To feminists, they were seen as limiting and oppressive: privileging ‘high’ art over low, ‘fine’ art over craft, men’s art over women’s” (10-11). To men, women’s art was seen as simply a craft and was not taken as seriously. The idea of defining art by the use of techniques in order to place a value on it was something that feminists strongly opposed as the emphasized the individual defining art according to his or her own values and experiences.

This is a painting by Georgia O’Keeffe called “Ice Cave.” When asked whether or not she was a feminist, she said she was not but it is argued that not only this painting, but many others, look like portrayals of a vagina. This would be considered to be lower feminine art because it is more of a social commentary on the idea of portraying the female body; it is not a sensual depiction of the female body that the male gaze would be attracted to. As a feminist and a woman in general, O’Keeffe obviously perceives the female body through a different gaze. The simple fact that the painting is by a feminine painter, regardless of whether or not she was feminist, would also make the perception of the painting much different, because of the perception that Brand and Korsmeyer discuss about how high art and genius were perceived as a patriarchal and masculine forte: “the universal subject is historically situated (masculine, patriarchal, imperialistic); and that the concept of fine or high art, along with the notion of artistic genius, is exclusionary both historically and conceptually” (8).

This type of art reminded me of the Cindy Sherman’s sculptures made from various different materials of very graphic female and sometimes male bodies. Sherman’s art, according to the definition from our visual literacy unit, would not have been considered high art because it is not the type of art you would see in a typical fine arts museum and define as fine in comparison to the type of modern museum sculpture. The exaggeration and boldness of the parts of the body that our society is most concerned about concealing unless it is “tastefully” and artistically portrayed, which to revert to the ‘male gaze’ idea, means that because they are not sensual and eroticizing the ideal female form, they are not very aesthetically pleasing.

In general, these two ideas that feminism brought about in the artistic realm converge into the main idea of rethinking what each of us values in art instead of categorizing ourselves into a “monolithic ‘we’” (Devereaux 136) determined by male versus female art of male versus female gaze. Instead of assuming that all men see pleasure only in art that eroticizes women and that women themselves cannot escape from also viewing art from a male gaze, each individual should seek their own values in art and beauty instead of conforming to the standpoint that has been established through societal norms of viewing. In Devereaux’s article, she suggests that in order to branch out into determining aesthetic merit in painting beyond the male gaze and idea that female art is of lower merit or perhaps simply a craft, a female gaze be developed: “Creating new artistic traditions provides an alternative to the passive reception of dominant traditions. This strategy is more often described as creating a female voice or female gaze. It allows women to write their own texts, their own history” (138). Whether or not that is possible is hard to determine, as individuals are so accustomed to the standards of viewing of today's society including how, as a comparatively modest culture, we view nudity in different art forms and also how we relate to men or women within art, as apparently even women have been coerced into conforming to the male point of view as a spectator. It's interesting to wonder if it is possible, after so many generations have been subject to viewing and creating from a common perspective, individuals can train themselves create or view art without, for example, any objectification or biased gender standpoints.

Maxine Post 6

Maxine Rivera

The consensus of our most recent readings indicate that gender does, with out a doubt, influence the formal components or art. This is not to say that a female artist will create distinctly feminine art which will differ greatly from distinctly masculine art, rather it is a realization of the influence that the "male gaze", as Devereaux puts it, has on all of us. On her very first page Devereaux discounts the possibility of unbiased art, whether the gaze is male or female, "no vision, not even artistic vision, is neutral vision."

First Point

Devereaux suggests that gender not only matters, but nearly dominates every aspect of the field. She explains that while there are three different views to consider, each of these views tends to relate back to the "male gaze." The views under consideration are those of the artist, the art created, and the spectator, any of which might be female, "the male gaze is not always male, but it is always male dominated." (P126) In this argument it is clear to see that gender is involved in every aspect of art, from the formal elements that compose it to the unsuspecting spectator who views it. The art is geared towards men and to promote patriarchal, masculine ideals. Devereaux quotes Simone de Beauvoir to further explain this, "Representation of the world, like the world itself, is the work of men; they describe it from their own point of view which they confuse as the absolute truth." (P127) Thus, the viewers of the art, which is being presented as Truth, become brainwashed into honestly believing that what they see is truth, whether they be male or female. The "male gaze" now reaches beyond the barriers of sex and gender and puts a pair of masculine lenses over the eyes of every individual. Of course when men are in control of the production and distribution of art, it seems obvious that art is going to take on a more masculine feel.




This image The Judgment of Paris by Girolamo di Benvenuto is a prime example of the male dominance in art that Devereaux discusses. She notes that "mythology defined the value of women as their value to men." Here Paris (the man) is making judgment on the women, the most beautiful just so happens to be the most naked, the one flaunting her body as though it was what made her valuable. Had Paris perhaps given the apple to one of the clothed women, the message of the painting might be empowering, but it seems that the women of most value is the one that provides the male with "voyeuristic pleasure." (p 132) The "male gaze" is present in this piece through the artist, the characters, (Paris is clearly demonstrating use of it and the women fall right into step) and the viewer who gets the subliminal message that for a woman to be aesthetically pleasing, or valuable she should flaunt her body.



In this painting, Study for the Judgment of Paris III the roles are reversed, here the woman seems to be judging three men. Initially a woman might feel vindicated, as though a wrong had been righted and equality restored, yet upon further analysis the "male gaze" seems to be present once more. First, the obvious, all the characters in this scene are fully clothed, again the woman seems to be wearing least clothes of all. Devereaux points out that even on the rare occasion that men serve as the scopophilic pleasure of the scene, they are rarely nude, they would feel "uncomfortable in such a role." (P132-133) Yet, the men, though being judged, still do not seem to be the erotic focus of this painting, the woman, in old Hollywood style, with her perfect hair, skinny body, and dainty cigarette still appears to be the erotic focus. Her position of control brings a new kind of sex appeal to the painting. Once again the woman seems to be in a position of dependence, she requires the fire (symbolic strength) of a man to achieve her goal ( a smoke.) While she has the power to choose, the painting seems to insinuate that she only has the power to choose from what is presented to her by a man, because she is incapable of acting for herself (perhaps pulling out a lighter.) The male gaze, once again send the message that even when a woman thinks she is in control, she is still dependent on a man.



A second point that suggests that gender is an impacting factor on art is the lack of recognition of female artists. If people honestly believed "that art and aesthetic attention are both in some sense universal" then why would there be a need to keep the female perspective quiet? (Brand, P 7) Brand describes how women's art became synonymous with "low art" or "craft" never achieving the artist the title of "genius" or "master" (terms associated with masculinity anyway.) (P10-11) In this way we look beyond formal concepts to the very production of art, if it was made by a woman, it would not receive equal consideration. This is evident in this piece,
by the Guerilla Girs. This image is a parody or sorts on The Grande Odalisque, a painting that displays yet another nude woman, posing. The striking color contrast pull attention and directs it to the gorilla's head in place of a woman's. The text in the piece gives the startling facts of how few women artists are featured in the Metropolitan Museum. The artist(s) also point out that in contrast, an overwhelming majority of the nude art works in the museum are of women. The imbalance proves the point that Brand is making about the lack of recognition for female artists, and how there is a difference between females creating art and females being featured in it.

This point is not supported by art alone, it is also supported by historical facts. For instance, women who created nude art (photographs, paintings, self portraits) were often turned away from museums and exhibits, had they served as the muse for a man however, the art would be accepted. They were kept from being curators, patrons, attending art schools, and buying art. (power point presentation) Based on these facts, and the art above, and countless other examples, it is clear to see that gender had everything to do with not only formal aspects of creating art, but also on the production and distribution of art.

Brynne post 6

Brynne Piotrowski

Examining art from a feminist perspective raises a myriad of issues, many quite controversial. Several of these issues rose to new levels of prominence in the past half-century, particularly in the 1960s and 1970s. In their respective writings, Brand and Devereaux address the question of whether gender is relevant to the traditional internal norms of the discipline of art. The authors find the answer overwhelmingly in favor of the affirmative.

One way in which Brand suggested the pertinence of gender to art was her discussion of “aesthetic perception” and the argument by classical aesthetic philosophers that, “the human mind should be considered in its basic components as a kind of generic subjectivity” (Brand 15). With this, the author introduces the concept of gender pertaining not only to the creation of art, but also to the perception of the works. Brand continues on to clarify the problem of gender in observing art as that of, “the culturally prescribed viewer: a male of dominant standing…the notion of the male gaze” (Brand 16). Devereaux devotes a considerable portion of her essay to the “male gaze” and notes that, “the male gaze remains difficult to understand…in part because…the male gaze refers both to literal and metaphorical vision” (Devereaux 126). She summarizes her description of the “male gaze” with the explanation that, “The male gaze is not always male, but it is always male-dominated” (Devereaux 126).

There is definite validity to “the notion of a male gaze,” and evidence in the art realm is copious. As the Guerrilla Girls pointed out in one of their advertisements included in the slide presentation, “Less than 5% of the artist in the Modern Art sections [of the Metropolitan Museum of Art] are women, but 85% of the nudes are female.” The visual work mimicked in this Guerilla Girls ad is an 1814 work by Jean-Auguste-Dominique Ingres titled The Grand Odalisque. This painting is only one of thousands, if not more, that reinforce the concept of the average viewer as male.



Guerrilla Girls






The Grande Odalisque
Ingres, Jean-Auguste-Dominique
1814



The formal components and artistic choices made by artists often reflect the idea of a male-gendered viewer as a work’s primary audience. The prevalence of the “male gaze” is a reflection upon gender in the production aspect of art. Prior to the Renaissance (roughly the 15th and 16th centuries), artists primarily served at the pleasure of patrons with little emphasis placed on the individual artist’s preferences or feelings. However, even after the patronage system began to be replaced by artists creating for their own pleasure, the “male gaze” continued to dominate art. Therefore, neither the patrons nor the artists can be fully blamed for the “male gaze” in art’s production, yet it is still a primary issue in the discussion of gender’s effect on art.

Another issue addressed by Devereaux in relation to gender’s role in art is how society responds to “the disequilibrium in power between the sexes,” which is contributed to by art (Devereaux 138). The disequilibrium, to Devereaux, is not the debatable issue. What is under scrutiny is how to deal with it. I want to focus particularly on Devereaux’s proposed solution of, “Creating new artistic traditions…often described as creating a female voice or female gaze” (Devereaux 138).

What sort of formal components or artistic conventions embody a “female gaze?” There is definitely a body of “feminine art,” but what requirements must be met for art to hold a “female voice?” The Guerrilla Girls offer their commentary (from another slide in Dr. Musgrave’s presentation) that merely being a woman artist means “Being reassured that whatever kind of art you make it will be labeled feminine.”

The film clips on Cindy Sherman and Hannah Wilke demonstrate that some female artists do not avoid disturbing depictions of the nude female. Alternatively, one could examine Judy Chicago’s Dinner Party (picture and link to in-depth description below) as an effort at creating a “female voice.” Chicago approaches the challenge from a completely different angle. She seeks to induce awe in the viewer with a collection of prominent women throughout history, rather than the exploitative and shocking works of Sherman and Wilke. Another example of femininity and art is Miriam Schapiro. Schapiro is surprisingly “traditional” compared to Chicago, Sherman and Wilke, but she maintains an interest in furthering the “female voice.” Her work below demonstrates Schapiro’s use of many formal components that are unlike those employed by the other three “female artists” heretofore discussed—abstraction, vivid color, and even the use of the more “traditional” acrylic, fabric, and canvas mediums.*





Dinner Party
Chicago, Judy
1974-1979
In-Depth Description: http://www.throughtheflower.org/page.php?p=10&n=2




I'm Dancing As Fast As I Can
Shapiro, Miriam
1984


So, with such a diverse body of works, how is there to be a “female gaze” or a “female voice?” The answer is not forthcoming, if there can be one at all. Gender definitely affects art, but the works of female artists are so diverse that defining a common “female voice” is beyond my grasp. One could even argue that there are “women artists” (i.e. Schapiro) and then there are “artists of women” (i.e. Sherman, Wilke). Belonging to one group does not preclude belonging to the other, but there are distinct differences among the two. Common formal conventions and artistic choices are largely indiscernible in such a varied body of work as that created by female artists, so creation of a “female gaze” cannot be characterized by such concepts.

Brand and Devereaux discuss how gender shapes various aspects of art. There is evidence to support the notion of a “male gaze” and, therefore, an opening to reflect upon the role of gender in art’s creation (such as subject, theme, etc.) and perception by a viewer. However, Devereaux’s suggestion of “creating a female voice or female gaze” proves much more problematic due to the wide variety of works by female artists. Female artists have proven talented, purposed, and sometimes even exploitive. There is no clear connection between art by females and artistic choices or formal conventions. As time and scholarship progress there will be continued opportunities to further explore the question of gender affecting art, the “male gaze,” and the potential for creating a distinctly “female gaze” or “female voice” within the realm of art.

*Technical information on Miriam Schapiro’s work comes from ARTstor.