Wednesday, October 3, 2007

Morgan, Post 6

Morgan Frost


Brand and Korsmeyer suggest the possibility that the genders of the artists “are to count as properties of works of art and to be recognized as aesthetically relevant” (Brand 16). But as Devereux points out, it is not exactly the gender of the artist that is important, but rather the gender of the artist’s perspective. Devereaux recognizes that “both men and women have learned to see the world through male eyes.” This is to say that women have come to judge through the accepted “standards of what is pleasing to men” (Devereaux 122). With this knowledge we see the argument that gender matters to the creation of art. While Brand and Korsemeyer merely offer the suggestion in their “Introduction,” Devereaux delves further and offers the example of film who is created by women but that are still manipulated by the male gaze: Maya Deren, Dorothy Arzner, Leni Riefenstahl (Devereaux 126). This is not only attributed to the traditional method of evaluating previously discussed, but also to the system in which the art is produced and who is in control of this system. Devereaux notes that “not all films have male authors, but whoever makes movies must work nonetheless within a system owned and operated by men” (Devereaux 126). The same can be said of pieces of art other than film. With this analysis, it becomes apparent that we must not only examine who is creating these images, but who will be the exhibitioner of the product.

Both of these pieces of work are created by women. They also portray exactly what Devereaux discusses in terms of seeing art through the “male gaze” whether a person is male or female (Devereax 122). Both pieces here portray the woman’s body as a sensual object—the curves of the woman’s figure being more colorfully displayed in the first image than the blunt focus on the genitalia of the women in the second image. Devereaux claims that “movies promote a way of seeing that takes man as subject, woman as object” (Devereaux 127). This applies to other forms of art as well, such as we see with the pieces I have selected above. The women are portrayed as objects of sexual desire, which reveals the male gaze through which these women artists created their work.

Gender also matters in the aspect of accepting art. If the female viewer in possession of the male gaze observes pieces of work that portray the female as an object, then a “level of female narcissism” can be manifested in her acceptance of the art (Devereaux 130). Through objectifying art containing women, one can distinguish the “assignment of positions” that the woman embodies (Devereaux 130). For example, in the following painting artist Velazquez portrays the goddess Venus being shown a mirror as she poses nude. Her expression is of pleasurable content. With this we can infer that she has not only accepted her role as the object of a male gaze in this painting, but she has embraced it. This is the “female narcissism” Devereaux describes, and it is an important factor in the power structure between the object and its onlooker. If such pride is taken in being the admired object, then we can also question the responsibility for the oppression of women as objects. Placing some amount of responsibility in the hands of women does not justify female oppression whatsoever. What it can do, though, is identify an important element in the removal of this oppression—the responsibility of women as the oppressed to change their own perspectives as well as men.

etibbetts post 6

erics tibbetts

Devereaux’s main point in her article, Oppressive Texts, etc. is that art created in the Western world almost from the beginning of time has been created within the parameters of the “male gaze”. This means that the creator, the created, the viewer for whom the art is created and the viewer who perceives the created art all have a view that is somehow affected by the patriarchal society in which the art, artist and viewer exist. Even if the artist, subject matter, and viewer are female, the art can still be considered to be affected by the male gaze. Devereaux calls this male gaze, “a way of seeing that takes women as its object” and quotes Laura Mavey who says, “Man is the bearer of the gaze, woman its object.” (Deveraux) This means that women are considered pleasing subject matter, that they are appreciated for their aesthetic value and that the art portraying them is directed at a male audience. However, this gaze applies even when women are not the sole subject matter of men the sole viewer, because of the traditions surrounding the creation and viewing of art. As Devereaux points out, “All vision is colored by the spectacles through which we see the world.” (Deveraux). Any artist who is educated and who creates within a patriarchal society will consciously or not create art that caters to the male gaze, unless he or she makes an effort to do otherwise, and even in doing this, he or she will be acknowledging the male gaze by specifically striving against it. Any viewer with the same background or education will also struggle to avoid viewing things through the lenses created by the male driven society. As Devereaux explains, “The spectator’s gaze is male in two senses, both in the direction at women as objects of erotic fascination and its in identification with the male protagonist.” (Devereaux).
So, in terms of images, the male gaze lets the artist make one of two decisions: to create art that fits within the parameters created by the male gaze, or to acknowledge the male gaze and the requirements it usually creates and to fight against these. Even in acknowledging these requirements though, feminist art empowers the male simply by trying to break away from it. In the case of art Judy Chicago’s “Dinner Party” female figures of the past are saluted and given importance in their own fields. However, even this piece makes something of a specatacle of the female body by making each of the “plates” at the individual place settings more and more elaborate and eventually turning them into sculptural pieces resembling vaginas. While this gives the piece a powerful visual component, it also calls attention to the sexuality of women (not necessarily a bad thing) but it shifts the viewer’s gaze back to the very thing a feminist piece might be struggling to escape. If an artist wants to escape the stereotypes created by the male gaze, might he or she not create something that does not strive to be interesting visually by displaying sexuality.
Cindy Sherman’s Sex series pieces strike me as much the same. Here we are presented with strangely grotesque figures with overlarge breasts, bent in awkward positions, and all explicitly sexual in one way or another. This art seems to be aimed at shocking the viewer and creating some sort of dialogue about the fact that women are commoditized or stereotyped by their appearance. While this is a valid point to be making, and I guess I agree with the message she wants to send about the inequalities/double standard created by the male gaze, I think in a way she creates works of art that somehow also fit into this culture. Her later work, in which she mocks film stills and looks at stereotypical female poses and roles, I think function almost as well, if not better, without the shock value created in the early work. In these black and white stills she seems to create a more subtle critique that does not sexualize the women as much. However, she is still portraying the female for observation by the male. Maybe art cannot change culture; maybe culture has to change before art can be viewed outside of the male gaze.
Devereaux quotes Sandra Batky in saying, ““girls learn to appraise themselves as they are shortly to be appraised” (and) in this sense, the eyes are female, but the gaze is male” (Devereaux). She discusses the male gaze in film, and how even though the filmmaker may be female, the film is still made for a male artist, and the subject matter still caters to men. Devereaux explains that women can still take part and enjoy this viewing because “ the spectator (can) revert at least imaginatively, to the active independence of what Freud termed the female child’s ‘early masculine period”. In this phase, she takes pleasure in a freedom that correct femininity will later repress.” (Devereaux) So, Devereaux allows that the female can take pleasure in the male gaze, but that she must do it from a prepubescent masculine time in her life.
I think the problem with this argument is that it almost doesn’t allow for a feminine appreciation of art, without admitting to masculine qualities. Thus, any female who appreciates art seems to be supporting a male dominated society. Devereaux states that art is controlled by the male gaze, that it is thus dominated no matter who makes it nor who views it, and seems to allow for almost no ability to change this domination. She questions the cannon, she questions the idea of universal art, she questions any way of viewing art outside of its political and social implications. While I don’t disagree with her, I really wonder if there is any way for art to change itself. I think culture and society must change before art can be viewed in anyway other than by the male gaze.
Brand and Korsymeyer agree with Devereaux when she points out that “the value of art is linked with the special mind of artists, and thus these theories give rise to a picture of the artistic Genius, a figure deeply inflected with masculine properties both historically and conceptually”, so that any idea of traditional artistic qualities becomes marred (at least in the eyes of the feminist) by the masculine ideal. (Brand) Any idea of an artistic “master” or artistic genius becomes firmly entrenched in the masculine ideal because all of the master throughout the history of art have been male, and the genius masculine, and all of the artists and critics male. Thus, a feminist looking at most accepted traditions in art must reject them for being male. However, in recent years the knowledge of past women artists has increased, as more classes are being taught about their existence in the past, and more opportunities are opening up at galleries and in exhibitions as the workforce in general allows for more female. This article stresses the gap between the study of aesthetics, philosophy of art, and feminism. Brand points out that, “Subjects mentioning women and gender have been very difficult to insert into analytic philosophy generally, for the simple reason that no such topics were considered “philosophical”. Part of the early resistance of analytic philosophy to the advent of feminist philosophy feminist perspectives in scholarship stemmed from the belief that subjects that specify gender digress into another discipline, one that deals in empirical data but not the abstract theorizing that marks philosophy.” (Brand) So, even art philosophers seem to reject feminism as being too grounded in the mundane and everyday problems of representation, viewership, etc.
It seems that, again, feminist issues with inclusion and equality are avoided for the sake of the male gaze, and the fact that the very philosophers who are excluding them are doing so due to the idea of their insignificance as a discipline.
While female artists are more common now then they have ever been, or are more commonly recognized now than they have ever been, there is still an under-representation, and a devaluation of the female art. Still, the work of women like Eva Hesse is seen as more craft-based and “feminine” than the heavier structure of artists such as Richard Serra or Donald Judd. Although, again, I doubt that the artists themselves can make much of a difference in this department, the fact that women are being included in exhibitions, and their works taught in classes, does mean that the culture is moving towards a more inclusive canon.

Kim post 6







According to both Brand and Devereaux, the “gaze” of a male viewer restricts the possibilities for the representation of the female form. This conclusion can be drawn by examining the patriarchal system that paves the road for the majority of past and present artworks. The basic idea is that any represented female form, or any image for that matter, must be presented in a way that is pleasing to the eye of a male. For a piece to be aesthetically pleasing, it must be pleasing to a man’s eye, and for a piece to be inspiring or intellectual, it must be seen as such to a man’s eye, and so on. The generalized idea that an image or piece of text is viewed from a male perspective has been with us for centuries. Even more so than today, men of the early twentieth century were seen as the bread-winners of the family, and therefore, they were the ones educated. Many more men were exposed to literature and high levels of art than women as part of their “male educations.” The “female education” of the time included things like cooking, baking, cleaning, and how to keep a proper home; for women, a formal education was not on the agenda.

With the idea of women as the “objects” of artwork, (Devereaux 121) one must take into consideration all that that entails. As the object of a contemporary piece of artwork, the female must be physically attractive, and follow the social norms of beauty: including body type, weight, hair color, eye color, and confidence. The female is presented to the viewers in a way that is purely for their satisfaction; a way that does not enable her to stand on her own, but instead presents her almost as a gift, often erotic and sometimes degrading. Barbara Kruger’s piece, You Are Not Yourself, exemplifies the struggles women face to make themselves “pretty enough,” “skinny enough,” and “good enough,” in the eyes of the men in their lives. The image shows what appears to be a broken mirror, with the face of a distraught woman looking back at the viewer. She seems to be crying over her appearance, and one might conclude that she has broken the mirror herself. The woman in the artwork has “cracked” under the societal pressures to look impossibly beautiful, and the text, “You are not yourself” refers to her lack of identity. In the process of conforming to what is expected of her, she has lost her personal identity, and her mind: an obvious criticism of the expectation of women, and the depictions of women in art.

The next image, Kristen Justesen’s “Sculpture II” depicts a nude woman in a small cardboard box. Extreme as it is, this picture neither shocks nor surprises me. Ironically though, if the sculpture were of a man depicted nude inside a box, I would be surprised. This is in part due to my awareness of feminist artwork, but mainly because it would be rare to find a piece of artwork in which a man depicts himself confined in any small space, especially as a representation of his restricted creativity. In this way, this image is a perfect example of the way many women artists are feel about their talent: they are confined to working within a fixed parameter, with no hopes of escaping the realm of judgment, or expanding the “accepted” social norms. Taken in another way, this image could also represent a rejection of the male “gaze.” The female form is stripped bare and placed in a confined space so ease in viewing. Presented in an “unladylike” manner, the woman rejects the traditional role of an art object. She appears unaffected by the viewer’s gaze on her, even going as far as to exhibit characteristics that would be seen as undesirable for a stereotypical patriarchal sculpture or painting.

In addition to the idea of the restriction of female forms in art, Devereaux and Brand’s articles pay particular attention to the “omission of the “greats” in written histories of art.” (Brand 10) Not only must a female form be aesthetically pleasing to the male viewer, but a majority of the time she is actually represented by a male. To further this idea, let’s examine a painting by one of the world’s “greats.” The Mona Lisa, by Leonardo DaVinci is both a prime example of men representing women, and the instrumental “gaze” cast on the image. Unlike many other traditional artworks of women, such as Kristen Justesen’s sculpture, the lady in the painting returns the viewer’s gaze. The infamous smile on her face takes the viewer back, as they are not used to the seemingly two-sided speculation. Breaking the traditional idea of “unauthorized looking,” (Devereaux 132) the figure seems to accept the fact that she is being watched. The mysterious smile on her face could even be described as telling, showing her pleasure, dissatisfaction or amusement with the viewer. The idealized form of the Mona Lisa proves yet again, the restrictions placed on women in art. She is presented as a lady of a high class, with appropriate clothing and hairstyle, as well as body type.

In sharp contrast to what is arguably Da Vinci’s masterpiece, is Marcel Duchamp’s Dadaist rendition of the same piece. Known by most for his work, The Fountain, Duchamp worked within the Dada and Surrealist movements during the post-World War II era. His unique depiction of the Mona Lisa, can be seen as both a rebelling of traditional Realism and a feminist critique. In his work, the figure appears with precise likeness to the original figure of the Mona Lisa, except for the inclusion of a petite mustache and beard. In this found-object piece, it appears that all Duchamp really did was take an already existing postcard of the Mona Lisa and deface it with a black pen. While in reality this may be true, his finished work has a much more significant meaning. While his intentions may have differed, an important criticism Duchamp’s piece makes is the oppressive representation of women. Through creating a female form with masculine qualities, he is actually broadening the range of acceptable looks for females in art. Taking into his account his position as a male artist, one might be able to perceive the relevant irony. Though an outsider to the world of socially acceptable art, Marcel Duchamp became famous with the help of his gender, and his work was eventually taken seriously. Would the same situation involving a female artist have the same outcome? I do not believe so. However, it is because of pro-active men, such as Marcel Duchamp, that feminist art has come as far as it has today. Dwelling on a reading from another class, oppression will not end until the oppressed people enlighten their oppressors; and consequently, the oppressors are the only ones who have the power to change the hierarchy of society.

Monday, October 1, 2007

Amanda D. Post #6

Amanda Dhillon

Gender seems to have a very strong relation to the formal components of art and of artistic choices, particularly when it comes to images. Devereaux argues that gender creates a bias on an entire work of art because the piece, whether by man or woman, is made to be viewed through what she calls the “male gaze” (Devereaux 121.) Essentially, this means that society throughout history was and still is (to varying degrees) patriarchal and structured to please and appeal to the male population. This is no different, then, in the art world as well. The focus of the art, the artistic choices and formal composition, are defined by what the male viewer will want to see. For instance, two paintings by seventeenth century artist Sir Peter Lely, Margaret Hughes and Eleanor Gwyn, both portraying two young mistresses of two different kings, are geared toward the male viewer. First of all, they are portraits painted of the mistresses of powerful men. This in itself instantly objectifies the women in the pieces, demonstrating the degradation of the female in art into a sensual object for the pleasure of the male audience. Second, Lely portrays each of them in a rather seductive pose and had chosen to position their bodices open (in the case of Margaret Hughes) or falling suggestively off the shoulders (in the painting of Eleanor Gwyn), which is quite obviously an example of a formal component of the piece that the male artist chose to depict as such in order to give the overall composition a sense of sensuality and make it pleasing to the men who will be viewing it. As for the women in the portraits, they end up becoming mere objects on display for the gazes of men. Even women artists in history have fallen victim to the widespread influence of the “male gaze.” Marguerite GĂ©rard’s Prelude to a Concert contains formal elements and compositional choices that create a sensual mood and make the subject, a woman about to rehearse a musical piece with a male accompanist, appear as a stereotypical woman, objectified and unable to contain her emotions around a man. At the surface, the artist’s choice of subject shows how women were considered objects not only in art but in life, as the woman needed to be proficient, to a degree, in the arts in order to have worth in the eyes of a society of men; she herself is an object that should have aesthetic and cultural value apart from the painting. Beyond this, the artist made the formal decisions to clothe her subject in an attention-grabbling white gown, which connotes physical purity, to fashion her expression into one of wonder and adoration at her male counterpart, and to include symbols of sensuality (www.nmwa.org) These would be the contrasting figures of the dog, which supposedly symbolizes “fidelity,” and a cat, which stands for “sexual promiscuity,” as well as the guitar, which the man holds and which represents the “female form” (www.nmwa.org.) These artistic choices influence the piece (perhaps subliminally and unknowingly) in favor of the male viewer through the woman’s transformation into an object filled with sexual desire for her male accompanist and the representations of the traditional role and expectations of women in the patriarchal society.

Gender also determines, according to authors Brand and Korsmeyer, the value of a work of art, defining “fine art” from “craft.” She points out how the “artistic Genius” (Brand 6) is only applied to the art of men, making it “fine art,” or an aesthetic masterpiece created purely to be admired for its beauty. On the other hand, then, women can only make “crafts” and other objects that are not considered artistically genius because they have function beyond decoration. For example, the eighteenth century female silversmith Elizabeth Godfrey created exquisite pieces such as the George II tea caddy and other detailed, embellished daily items. Though her work is undoubtedly beautiful and she enjoyed some success as a female silversmith, her art is not considered “fine art” in the way that, say, her contemporary Maurice de la Tour’s Madame Pompadour is; Godfrey creates everyday, useful objects such as tea sets, which in the male-dominated society do not achieve recognition as a piece created solely for its aesthetics. Therefore, the value of the woman’s art is lowered through societal standards established by men. It would also seem, then, that gender does have at least some influence in the “type of art produced by women” (Brand 16), and it might be true that this comes directly from the way that the patriarchal society regarded (and in some ways still does regard) females. Perhaps a connection can be drawn between a woman who is expected to work with household objects of everyday (quilts, clothing, cooking ware, serving ware, etc.) and the art that she makes being overwhelmingly domestic in nature or dealing with clothing and fashion, as they are the only aspects of life she knows well (or was allowed to participate in historically.) Accordingly, then, the female artist’s choices in creating a piece are governed by what is made familiar to her through the knowledge that a male-dominated society has allowed her to acquire.

Images used:

Madame Pompadour: http://www.all-art.org/rococo/images/boucher/Pompadour1.jpg

George II tea caddy: http://www.nmwa.org/collection/detail.asp?WorkID=5113

Eleanor Gwyn: http://www.wsu.edu/~dee/GRAPHICS/GALLERY/ENLIGHT/GWYN.JPG

Margaret Hughes: http://www.kipar.org/period-galleries/paintings/1670/hughes.jpg

Prelude to a Concert: http://www.bluffton.edu/courses/womenartists/womenartistspw/gerard/concert.jpg

Wednesday, September 26, 2007

Justin Wright post 5

Justin Wright

Post 5

Abstract art has been inflammatory in fascist, communist, and democratic nations. Interestingly, Americans who disliked Abstract Expressionism blamed a communist conspiracy for its prevalence and the Nazis called it Bolshevist, but the Soviets actually feared it. There was a small group of influential Americans who supported the Abstract Expressionist movement, a small group of antagonists, and the majority of people were completely apathetic. The Rockefeller family, the Central Intelligence Agency, and the Museum of Modern Art were all linked together in a sort of conspiracy to champion Abstract Expressionism during the start of the Cold War, and to showcase these types of works abroad as America’s culture. This would be a way of impressing the communist bloc with the culture that flourishes under democracy. But this had to be done quietly, because Congress feared Abstract Expressionism and was still mired in the McCarthyist hunts for traitors. The CIA allotted funding for overseas art shows that included Abstract Expressionist art. By diverting funding through itself, the CIA was able to allow these exhibits to tour that otherwise would not have been funded. Congress itself, and a good deal of the nation, was in favor of censorship of any work by an artist with “subversive” ties, regardless of content or how unfounded the claims. The scandal over Anton Refregier’s murals in the Rincon Annex was likely to have been the result if Congress was asked to make appropriations.

The reason that some Americans feared abstract expressionism was because of two unrelated reasons that they attempted to link. One was that some, but far from many, artists of Abstract Expressionist works had communist leanings. The other reason was that they were just plain disturbed by the works. The disproportional, the psychedelic, the abstract, and the cryptic were all frightening to most Americans who could not understand this new art, for the same reasons it bothered the Nazis. They questioned the skill of the artists because the technical skill needed for representational art was no longer needed. It looked like children could do this art, and this upset Americans who were fearful of the Soviets gaining the lead over them in any field. A loss of artistic talent was devastating. According to Jane de Hart Mathews, “the rejection of traditional forms and the commitment to abstraction that characterized vanguard art seemed to impart to their highly structured world the quality of chaos and the demonic that they so easily identified with communism.” (Art and Politics in Cold War America, page 162) Simply because Abstract Expressionism was “ugly,” that was enough to make it communist in the eyes of people like Senator George Dondero.

Abstract Expressionism was a deeper movement intellectually than representational art. Those viewing abstract art had to solve it because it was like a riddle; the meaning was not explicit. For a citizenry accustomed to traditionalist, realist art, this was not something they were expecting. People had not encountered the avant-garde before on such a scale. For post-World War II conservatives, the rejection of the traditional and the established was treason. This is another reason it was so easily identified with communism, because it ran contrary to established American culture.

This new art also required interpretation, and therefore originality. Some perceived the avant-garde as the efforts of communist traitors trying to force this new art upon an unwilling public, but others, including the CIA and MOMA, saw the potential of the art to champion the individual over the state. In Socialist Realism, the art was so representational that it could only mean one thing, and this was what the Soviets wanted in order to get the party message out to illiterate masses. Educated American capitalists, on the other hand, were capable of producing art that freed the artist from governmental restrictions and even the restrictions of reality itself, with at least a longer version of censorship’s leash than the communists allowed.

Censorship was a hot issue in the 1950’s and 60’s. The Rincon Annex fiasco scored a victory for Refregier’s murals and artistic freedom, because the changes recommended to be made to them failed. The murals were accused of being examples of Socialist Realism, another form identified (correctly) with communism. Whether or not they were Socialist Realism is debatable, since they were historically accurate about the plight of labor and events in San Francisco, but this would place them as Social Realism. The public feared anything that could have ties to communism, including Abstract Expressionism. Somehow the fact that abstract art was banned in Soviet Russia escaped declaration, and numerous groups always rose to protest anything done by an artist who had dubious ties, like Refregier. Several art exhibits scheduled to go overseas were canceled, because the directors refused to remove art by such artists solely for that reason, and this led to the government action. The exhibit “Sport in Art” was scheduled to go to Australia for the 1956 Olympics, but because four works by artists with subversive leanings were not removed, the USIA director reversed the decision to send the exhibit overseas.

Mountains and Sea

Helen Frankenthaler

Here, Helen Frankenthaler has depicted an abstract scene of mountains adjoining a sea. Discerning either of these things is difficult, especially since there are colors used for the mountains such as red and green, mixed with traditional grey and brown. Interestingly, this painting is so abstract that picturing the mountains from top down as well as a side view is possible. This demonstrates how abstract art can be interpreted, and relies on these interpretations for meaning rather than mimesis, much like a Rorschach test. For some people this art is meaningless, because nothing can be easily discerned. The sea exists as patches of blue without coherence, instead of a single body, and the mountains blend together into an amorphous mass rising out of the center. This landscape does not easily show the titular mountains and sea, and that is why this painting could be frustrating or disturbing to some.



Little Spanish Prison

Robert Motherwell

What exactly is in Motherwell’s painting? It appears like it could be three doors, two of them in a pair. The two conjoined ovals on the right look like a pair of hollow eyes staring within. It does appear frightening, and the title confirms this. This prison is devoid of any detail, a prison for the eyes, withholding stimulation. Since the painting just does not clearly depict anything, the viewer is at a loss of information. What else is going on? In a prison, the prisoner is subjected to the same deprivation about the outside world.

This painting is an example of Abstract Expressionism that does not clearly represent anything. It requires arduous, in depth contemplation to understand. Such contemplation can only be done by the intellectually free, and in this way abstract art is a show of artistic freedom. Others may view it as purely frightening, like a nightmare, but for its own sake and not for its message.




Onement IV

Barnett Newman

Apparently just a white line, Newman’s painting is the epitome of abstraction and simplicity. What this could represent is the single strand of time, the continuity of all that has ever happened, combined into one form, superimposed over the twilight of the abyss. In this, there is a separation between all being one, and oblivion. This separation is emphasized by the line dividing the backdrop in half.

The most obvious criticism to the painting would be “that’s it?” since there is only a line. The “my dog could do that” logic is the strongest argument against such abstraction. But also, total abstraction frees the artist of any responsibility to depict anything in particular. There can be no objection to the subject matter because it is indescribable. The only objection is due to how simple it really is.




R-no. 1

Clyfford Still

Another totally abstract painting, there is not even a title to explain what the representation could be. There is mostly crimson, with dashes of orange yellow, and what appear to be holes eaten through the reddish areas. It almost resembles paper degraded by insects. This painting recently went for over $21,000,000 at auction, which is totally inexplicable to most people. A painting that does not clearly represent a subject seems like it could not possibly be worth so much money, especially since many think they can make art of the same quality. Some could contend that the high price of Still’s work is evidence of a lack of taste on the part of art critics. But this is more strongly evidence of artistic freedom in a capitalist economy, where artists are free to produce what they like and the cultural value of the work is represented by its monetary worth to museums and collectors.






Hyena Stomp

Frank Stella

Frank Stella’s painting of a squared spiral appears to have more order than it actually does. The colors of the segments change randomly, sometimes as a gradient into a similar color, sometimes an abrupt shift. However, the colors do proceed in the same order when looking closely. Inevitably the viewer will follow this spiral, either inward or outward, as it is the only thing to focus on. The effect is somewhat hypnotic. Disappointingly there are no hyenas as the title implies.

This is another example of Abstract Expressionist art that is nonrepresentational and cryptic. This is frightening to those who “just don’t get it,” as well as a triumph of the individual, in the form of the artist as well as the viewer who is free to interpret the art, or to dismiss it.


Morgan, Post 5

Morgan Frost



It is important to note that unlike other genres such as realism, regionalism, etc., the art I have selected shows how American Abstract Expressionist art does not follow any particular theme or pattern. The fact that these pieces fall together under the umbrella of Abstract Expressionism is not a confinement to the content or the portrayal of the art, but instead it is the recognition that each of these pieces is instead quite the opposite of restrained. These paintings and sculptures are created by the individual artist with the respective artist’s own ideas of how and what to create. Each artist is expressing personal views. As I discussed with Professor Libby, this shows a power shift between artists and viewers throughout history. Previously, art had been used as a mode to capture and glorify the values of society (e.g. the Great German Art Exhibition, regionalism, etc.). During this time of the Cold War, however, Abstract Expressionism rises in America, and the responsibility shifts to the audience, who is no longer being fed material, but must interpret the art as presented by the artist.

It is in this individual freedom of expression that we find the dissecting opinions of the work as creative versus dangerous. Those who viewed pieces of Abstract Expressionist art as creative saw pieces of art such as these as representations of the freedom the American people valued. Chairman Whitney of The Museum of Modern Art saw that this type of art can be used to “inspire” free men to appreciate and utilize “their own freedom” (Cockcroft). Not only was this art seen to glorify the values of liberty within America, but many saw the opportunities this art provided of spreading this individual freedom around the world. Polish artist Cantor, for example, moved away from objective painting, and was welcomed into the arms of the MOMA with exhibitions (Cockcroft).

As far as connections to communism, supporters of Abstract Expressionism saw the artistic creativity as a manifestation and adoration of the freedom in American society, rather than the “regimented” and confined communist art within dictatorial regimes. Pieces such as these were “the perfect contrast to the regimented, traditional, and narrow nature of socialist realism” (Cockcroft). McCray and others of his time and rank in the art world used pieces of Abstract Expressionism in international affairs in order to exhibit this freedom of the mind present in America (Cockroft.)

Those who viewed Abstract Expressionist art as decadent or dangerous, however, often made a connection to communist ideals. With the rise of communism came new ideas about power and freedom, and thus the rejection of older, traditional views. This new form of art was a “rejection of traditional ways of seeing form and space,” and so the conclusion was that it must also be a “rejection of traditional world views” like communism was endeavoring upon. Many held on to the idea that the purpose of art was to be “pleasing and uplifting,” and criticized art that did not produce these feelings. The 29 murals done by Refregier depicting the history of San Francisco, for example, was even condemned as “disturbing” and the images were referred to as “Frankenstein monsters” by those who were disappointed in the work’s lack of pleasurable appeal. California’s Congressional representative Scudder directed the murals to be removed on the grounds that they were “derogatory” and “communist propaganda.” Anti-communists claimed that the modern works were a “conspiracy conceived in Russia” and were a “threat…to those loyal American artists who sought to protect their cultural heritage from the new forms”(Mathews). Thus any new form of art, in this case Abstract Expressionism, infringed upon the traditional values Americans were trying to uphold, and therefore must be communistic and decadent.

Ally, Post 5






Ally Best

post 5


The fact that Abstract Expressionism played a significant role during the Cold War is indisputable. However, what could be and, in fact, was disputed is what exactly this role was.

Through the Abstract Expressionist art and several clever propaganda ploys, the CIA attempted to convey to cultures abroad that the U.S. was “a free ‘society’ as opposed to the ‘regimented’ communist bloc” (Cockcroft, 150). Artists of this “new” style ignored the classical techniques, and even subject matter, to create truly unique pieces of art. As Eva Cockcroft explained, they were able to create a new artistic movement, “by giving their painting an individualist emphasis and eliminating recognizable subject matter.” They accomplished this artistic “freedom” in a variety of ways. Some artists, such as Willem de Kooning, took a common image and created it in a very different and abstract style. Willem’s painting titled “Woman V” depicts the basic outline of a human body. However, while the image certainly has a “womanly” chest, the figure’s shoulders are broad and masculine. Far from the conventional stereotypes of female beauty and delicacy, the face of the woman in this painting is distorted and almost grotesque. The random, bright splashes of color give the painting a somewhat chaotic feeling, as if the painting itself were actually radiating energy. Other pieces of artwork, such as Barnett Newman’s “Vir Heroicus Sublimis” or Mark Rothko’s “White Center,” were even more abstract, depicting large areas of solid color. These paintings, though simple in design, were oftentimes meant to provoke strong emotions in the reader through their clear and uncomplicated style. Critics who argued that Abstract Expressionist art was a symbol of America’s freedom of expression were, in general, politically motivated. In fact, the Museum of Modern Art proudly announced that the aim of its foreign program was “to let it be known especially in Europe that America was not the cultural backwater that the Russians, during that tense period called ‘the cold war,’ were trying to demonstrate that it was” (Cockcroft, 149). Through this “new, fresh and creative” style of art, politically minded individuals could boost the United States’ cultural status in the eyes of foreign countries by, for example, proving that the U.S. was “culturally up-to-date in competition with Paris” (Cockcroft, 151).

However, not everyone agreed with this liberal interpretation of Abstract Expressionist art. The other side of the argument “involved opposition on political rather than esthetic grounds” (Mathews, 156). This view was based on the reasoning that “rejection of traditional ways of seeing form and space inherent in vanguard style of painting implied rejection of traditional world views” (Mathews, 156). Unconventional works of art such as the harsh, jagged, and boldly vibrant paintings by Clyfford Still and the abstract, oddly robotic sculpture “Becca” by David Smith throw away the “traditional” concepts of artwork. Therefore, some might argue that these pieces of art were, in a way, unpatriotic because they suggested views very different from the norm. A few people even went as far as arguing that this movement “threatened not only art but the fundamental freedom of our American way of life” (Mathews, 164). To look at the difference in opinions between the supporters and opponents of Abstract Expressionism, one could consider Kooning’s “Woman V” from the more conservative viewpoint. Congressman Dondero explained that he “opposed modern art as ‘Communist’ because it bred ‘dissatisfaction’ by virtue of the fact that it was unintelligible to ordinary Americans whose ‘beautiful country’ it failed to ‘glorify,” and he “emphasized its distortion, grotesqueness, and grotesqueness of the painting as a freedom of expression, the conservative view was appalled by its lack of aesthetic appeal. Dondero went as far as claiming that this style of work was “nauseating” to him (Mathews, 165).

In reading articles about Abstract Expressionism and examining the two different viewpoints, I read a passage that seemed to clarify the controversy for me and that I feel is important to take into account. Eva Cockcroft notes that, “The artist creates freely. But his work is promoted and used by others for their own purposes” (154). The artists who created these works may or may not have had political aims. However, their artwork was interpreted by critics who more than likely had never even met them. Many of these critics of the works, unlike most of the artists who had created them, almost always had ulterior motives. Whether they were politicians attempting to improve the U.S.’s cultural image or traditional artists angry with the effect modern art had had on the popularity on their own type of art, they had something to gain by the success or failure of the art movement. As Mathews mentions, most Americans could simply “take it or leave it” and would not "confuse their esthetic judgment or preferences with political commitments" (156). Perhaps the American Federation of Arts' trustees said it best when they stated that art, "should be judged based on its merits as a work of art and not by the political or social views of the artist" (Cockcroft 152).